Jesus. I can completely relate to that. It took me several months after DDay to realize how big of a problem this is with WH.
When I moved out after DDay #3, he wrote me a letter he probably thought was romantic, saying that "My friends keep telling me to do the work for myself, not for you, but I don't even know what that means, because everything in my life is for you, and the only reason I do anything is for you."
Sounds sweet, but dig a little deeper and what he's saying is that he has no sense of self at all. He thinks there's no point in fixing himself unless he's doing it for my benefit. He'll be a liar if that makes me happy, or he'll work on himself if that makes me happy, or he'll say any damn thing I want to make me happy, just as long as I calm down and go back to rewarding him with kisses.
And yet, you know what would really make me happy? Standing proudly next to a guy who does the right thing because he couldn't live WITH HIMSELF if he didn't.
He's indicated multiple times during this process that his entire behavioral makeup is centered around whether or not other people are upset with him or not at that very moment. I'm still not certain he understands what it means to do the right thing because you know it's the right thing, no matter who's gonna be pissed.
When other people are mad at him, he squirms around trying to hit whatever behavior he can adopt, way of thinking he can espouse, or words he can say that will make the unpleasant anger stop at that exact moment. He's not motivated by an internal desire to tell the truth, but by an external push.
He told me once that during the worst part of his wayward behavior, when things were really bad, he told himself it was no big deal what he was doing, because no one was mad at him. This, of course, is because no one fucking knew what he was doing. But that didn't factor into his thinking.
We've had the same issue with lying and half-truthing. We went through several weeks in which he kept confessing that he had recently told me ANOTHER lie, and I'd get mad and ask him when we were going to get the point in our lives where no more lies from "last week" were being cleared up?
He then blurted out, "What am I supposed to do? You get mad if I don't lie to you and then you get mad when I confess that I did later."
I wanted to SCREAM. The entire basis of his morality is based on this dolphin-doing-a-trick-for-a-fish thing, it's shocking. If he gets instantly rewarded, it is good. If he's not getting instantly rewarded, it is bad. What's the point of humans evolving such big brains if we behave so basely? How about you just not tell lies because lying to your wife makes you feel guilty? And how about, when you realized you did lie, you tell me, not because it will get you a fish, but because you genuinely want no lies between us? Why is that concept so alien to him?
Because, as you said, his entire motivation, until the A, in all parts of his life, has been external. He sees and judges himself entirely based on external feedback. It's a big, big problem, because it means he not only has no integrity, he doesn't even know what it is.
I'm still VERY wary of this. No integrity is one of my dealbreakers, and I can't imagine not being freaked out about this until I see consistent, long-term proof that he's grown some self-worth. I'm starting to see signs of it, I think, but after all the TT, I don't know anymore. I've actually started worrying that since WH is getting rewarded by everyone for being on the right track now - his friends praise him for working on his shit, his parents pat him on the head for going to counselling, I try to reward him when he does something right, his IC is all touchy-lovey-feely - that we're just in a rewards part of the pattern and now that he's not in trouble every second, he'll be loathe to tell a hard truth and ruin the niceness.
I want him so badly to have enough of a sense of self that he'll risk being yelled at because the thought of not doing the right thing by me is a thought he can't live with.
He's working on it. We'll see what happens.
[This message edited by Thessalian at 2:04 AM, December 18th (Wednesday)]