MIL told me to take my gift back, that they only wanted money. (A few days later I received the invite with "Fee Shower" on it)
This Fee Shower I'm invited to now is MIL's goddaughter. I thought the term fee shower was just something MIL invented for her own daughter, but it looks like this other woman is having one, too.
Have you all heard of these. I am from a different region of the US than MIL, and I'm wondering if this is a regional thing. I am not close to the bride (location wise or emotional closeness) So my guess is that they invited every woman who is invited to the wedding to the shower. (its a big wedding, so probably 150 women are invited to the fee shower)
Where I live, bridal showers are your friends getting together, giving you a blender or lingerie, and laughing and eating. Curious if this is a regional thing.
[This message edited by Gottagetthrough at 1:37 AM, April 29th (Tuesday)]
To me, the wedding is when you usually give a money gift so the couple can have a bit to start a nest egg or to pay for a honeymoon or buy furniture for their new place, etc. The shower is to give an actual gift that the bride can use in setting up her new home.
I know the lines get blurred if the couple has been living together for a while and they already have all of that stuff. But, to me, that's the fun of it. I like to pick out a gift that I think they will like and use. I like to see the other gifts too. It's not a whole lot of fun if the bride just has a bunch of envelopes full of cash.
"You must try to generate happiness within yourself. If you aren't happy in one place, chances are you won't be happy anyplace." Ernie Banks
I think they are tacky.
IMO if the couple has been living together and they aren't in need why throw a party to get cash? It used to be to help the young couple get a head start.
I give a gift for the shower and cash for the wedding.
I was invited to a wedding last year, couple in their thirties. They went on vacations like i have never seen. Six months before the wedding they set up a web site asking for donations for their honeymoon. I thought it was really odd. They also had the traditional shower, so it wasn't in lieu of.....
I don't get invited to showers or parties much that require gifts, but if someone were to say "cash only", my RSVP would be a not attending.
I think that's tacky.
I gave you more than I ever got back
You left me here to forget about that
All the things you thought you had have gone
Let that be a lesson to you
-Richie Kotzen, "Special"
If I could afford to give $100 then I would, but if I couldn't? Then I wouldn't. It's pretty simple from that end. And if someone tries to shame you for not giving money that you can't afford? Then tell them, "well, I really needed to pay my electric bill this month" or something like that. You know, to put it in perspective.
[This message edited by cayc at 7:01 AM, April 29th, 2014 (Tuesday)]
My sister tried giving me a Jack and Jill and I told her that a regular bridal shower is fine with me. That's what I had.
I wouldn't go, and I don't think I would even RSVP. If they ask tell them you never got the invitation.
My H and I were together almost 8 years by the time we finished school and got married, and a big part of me not having a giant wedding was the obligation that I would put on others to spend money on me. It just seemed so flipping tacky. My mom of course insisted I send out an announcement to all of their friends, and I did include a statement of no gifts necessary. We did get some money from some of them, but again, I didn't expect it.
I can even go along with registering at Home Depot or Lowes, and giving gift cards for those places, esp if they are just purchasing a home. But to just flat out ask for money. No. Ick. How disgustingly materialistic can you be.
I can't phathom asking for money - for any event. Ever.
To me, charity and gift-giving comes from the heart - not at the prompting of an invitation.
I think I'm OK with being "old" because I'm not OK with Fee Showers, Greenback Showers, Cash Only, and so-on.
....Now back in my day what we received as wedding gifts are now shower gifts. Times how they have changed in 42 years!
[This message edited by looking forward at 10:01 AM, April 29th (Tuesday)]
This is the first M for both of them, however they are in their mid-30's so they already have a lot of the basics that they need (they are not living together). Because of that, a lot of stuff on their registry is expensive...they are registered for china, crystal, etc.
The bride realizes this and she mentioned she would be happy with anything, even if someone bought just a single glass. They are also registered for their honeymoon. I actually like that idea! I think it's nice that I can buy them a parasailing trip, or a wine and cheese tray. Also, the honeymoon registry is broken up. Let's say you wanted to contribute to them going parasailing, but it costs $120. They have it broken up into $30 increments so many people can help buy them that experience.
I do agree that it's tacky to just ask for money though. I'm uncomfortable just giving money because I feel like I'm being judged for how much I give. It's the same way I feel when giving gift cards to my kids teachers.
Maybe it's a cultural/regional thing. At my wedding one of my neighbors, whom I had known since I was a child, asked when we were doing the money dance. I had no idea what that was. She told me it was when people gave money to dance with the bride. She said it was a Polish tradition. Whether or not that's true, I don't know.
If you're not close to the bride, send a lovely card and your regrets that you won't be able to make it to the shower.
Trust is like paper. Once it's crumpled it can never be perfect again.
Hell, some people have dances at the wedding where you pin money to the bride. I refused that tradition too.
Call me a rebel
When my SIL got married 20+ years ago, people asked her what they needed. "Money". I was embarrassed to be her bridesmaid.
She also handed out the wedding invitations at the bridal shower. Even more tacky.
OMG. Have an ounce of class, please.
Former 80s Icon wishful thinking
I've given money and/or gift cards as wedding gifts plenty of times, but I've never specifically been asked to. It may be the way things are now, but it seems tacky to me.
My lawn. Get off it.
"And never grow a wishbone, daughter, where your backbone ought to be."
- Sarah McMane
I thought that was an INCREDIBLY generous and kind-hearted thing to do. By asking for this, they made it not only just about them, but about causes that help people who are TRULY in need.
I generally give money only to relatives for wedding gifts, otherwise I buy a gift from the registry. I have given money for my nieces shower that I could not attend because it was easier than trying to send a gift. I could have rsvp'ed that I could not attend and not send anything, but I really wanted to give something to my niece.
When my nephew got M my sister mentioned to everyone in the family that they really needed a new dishwasher and planned to use any home depot gift cards that they received for the purchase. But this was only to us siblings and we are close and she simply mentioned it. They were flooded with Home Depot cards and were able to purchase the dishwasher before all the guests arrived at their house
But to blatantly say that you EXPECT a monetary gift is beyond tacky. I wonder, does the bride to be then open all the "gifts" at the shower and announce the amount of the check?
I went to a money tree shower. We were supposed to put money in an envelope and then hang the envelope from a tree. I guess it is basically the same thing. I gave them an envelope with a picture of the Kitchen Aid blender I bought them. LOLOL
[This message edited by Mack9512 at 12:20 PM, April 29th (Tuesday)]