Return to Forum List

Return to The Book Club® > The Book Club

You are not logged in. Login here or register.

Gone Girl

Pages: 1 · 2

traicionada posted 5/13/2013 11:15 AM

I just finished reading and I can help to feel super disappointmented Most of the characters were plain broken people so I'm inclined to think I never connected with any of them.

wildbananas posted 5/13/2013 13:35 PM

I liked it in that it was a good, psychological thriller/story and I was always racing ahead to find out what happened next but yeah... I have to say I didn't like any of the main characters much at all. It was hard to root for any of them.

meaniemouse posted 5/13/2013 23:54 PM

Count me in. I raced through and felt really angry at all of the characters in the end.

20WrongsVs1 posted 5/15/2013 06:48 AM

It was, at least, unique.

Too_Trusting posted 5/21/2013 05:39 AM

I hated both of the characters too, but OMG - I could NOT put that book down.

Tripletrouble posted 5/21/2013 16:00 PM

It was right after reading this my WH signed up for his secret life on AFF. I can't help but feel like the book factored in his intrigue with a secret life.

ms521 posted 5/22/2013 19:49 PM

I remember reading it and wondering what all the hype was. Figured it was the overdone story of some guy who offs his wife to clear his path for other women. Whatever.

I couldn't put it down because I was waiting for him to get caught. And I was happily surprised by the ending in that I thought the characters deserved each other.

nolight posted 6/3/2013 15:41 PM

I liked Amy allot until mid way through then ended up disliking both of them but I found a fair bit of what she said to be true too..

I don't think you always have to identity with a character, these were two very broken and utterly dislikable people. I've just finished the book and its the first time in awhile that a book has made me really think about my feelings about the characters I was reading about. I'm excited to read her other novels!

[This message edited by nolight at 4:02 PM, June 3rd (Monday)]

neverendinghurt posted 11/9/2013 10:46 AM

I have just finished reading Gone Girl and had to come here to read what others thought.

Some parts of it triggered me, and my Dday was 7 years ago.

I did wonder several time sif the author has been a member here, it seemed to me that she may have experienced infidelity at some point.

As for the book, I think the author started out with a good storyline which she spoiled by making Amy psychopath.

scaredyKat posted 11/10/2013 13:19 PM

Unique, to be sure. That was the best part about it... totally unlikeable characters.

circe posted 11/10/2013 13:56 PM

I actually loved that the two main characters were so awful and unlikeable. I thought it was a unique way to handle the book. The husband! Omg, how icky he was! And the wife! Once I gave up trying to relate to either of them and just sat back and watched the trainwreck unfold it was a great story.

PurpleRose posted 11/26/2013 21:05 PM

I agree- it's rare that I hate both main characters in a book! I loved that they got what they deserved in the end- each other!

Skye posted 11/27/2013 13:46 PM

I hated it, but I'm now reading "The Silent Wife," which is very similar but, imho, a much better book--maybe because both husband and wife are very "normal" to me, compared to the "Gone Girl" characters.

prowoman posted 11/27/2013 17:11 PM

Agree with so many. Loved the story, hated the characters, and ended up liking the fact that the characters were so unlikeable. The analogy of watching a train wreck unfold... spot on.

teacheribe posted 12/20/2013 18:43 PM

The movie Gone Girl is to come out next year.

circe posted 12/26/2013 06:04 AM

I recently listened to this as an audiobook on a long drive, and I have to say that one of the things I liked about it was that I hated the husband so much (he reminds me very much of my xH) that I was almost glad that Amy was who she was, as she could do this almost fantasy version of revenge that "normal" people could never do.

I don't know if you guys have seen the series Luther on Netflix, but there's a female character who is a psychopath that the main character nearly comes to rely on, as she does things a moral person would never do, but that on some inner level a moral person might secretly wish would happen.

Though I may just have felt this way because during the holidays I've had to interact more with my xH, who seems fairly normal these days but in the past was very much like Nick - helpless, lazy, self centered, addicted to unearned praise, shallow, always saw himself as the victim, even when he was doing something terrible. When I listened to the book in audio form I ended up picturing my ex as Nick and so in my mind I was glad he ended up with Amy as his wife.

I checked out the cast list for the movie - Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike. ?? I don't know if I would have pictured Ben Affleck, but ok.

NeverAgain0 posted 9/4/2014 12:24 PM

I'm ready for the movie!!

pizzalover posted 9/4/2014 17:55 PM

Me too! I loved the book!

Popper posted 9/6/2014 19:09 PM

I was intrigued but HATED the ending! Awful

redsox13 posted 9/9/2014 12:45 PM

Good read - but the first 30% of the book reads very different from the ending.

solus sto posted 9/13/2014 18:26 PM

The book pissed me off. The author likes writing unlikeable characters--and succeeded in spades.

But the ending just pissed me off. When I devote time to a book, especially one with so much conflict, I want some sort of... Payoff. Didn't get it.

I wish Affleck weren't in the movie. I think it might be better on screen. But I suspect that I will leave a theater pissed off, too. (Don't go, right? I won't. But I'll watch it On Demand--and it will still piss me off! Clearly I am a glutton for punishment--a lifetime with personality disordered people draws me to stories like this--I keep trying to figure out the un-figure-out able. Silly me.)

[This message edited by solus sto at 6:27 PM, September 13th (Saturday)]

Pages: 1 · 2

Return to Forum List

Return to The Book Club

© 2002-2015 ®. All Rights Reserved.