I took an SI hiatus but have recently been lurking a little...mostly because I decided to start dating for the first time since the D and was needing a little support.
I had a 1 month long relationship with a man from OLD which ended very suddenly. I'm thankful to him for ending it quickly enough that I was able to let go fairly easily. I'm thankful to Google for showing me that while we were dating he was using a profile on a second site other than the one I met him on, despite telling me he was no longer dating online bc I was so wonderful he only wanted me...ick! And I'm thankful to my hormones for holding out on sex despite really, really wanting him to sweep me off the bus...or lay me down on the floor of the bus and...whew! Sorry. I was very attracted to him.
Anyway...my actual issue is this:
I've been talking to and seeing a man, also from OLD, who told me on our first date that he is divorced. He said 3 years ago his ex-wife told him she'd been having an A, that every time she said she was visiting her mother she was really going to see her AP. She is now married to her AP and they have kids together.
I recently looked at his profile again for the first time in weeks and realized he listed himself as never married. I thought that was a deal breaker because it's a lie and confronted him about it. He said that part of his life is very private and is not something he's comfortable sharing with strangers.
After we talked about it, he said he'd like us to be exclusive because he knows for sure he wants to be with me, that he's not seeing anyone else and doesn't want to share me. I told him it's way too soon and he said he'd wait but he knows he doesn't need more time, that he feels I'm the right one for him and has known it since he first saw me. *eyeroll* ...maybe I'm too cynical but I think that's silly. It's been less than a month!
Soo....is this an automatic deal breaker? At first I thought a lie is a lie and I have to be out, but I'm also wondering if it's sometimes more complicated than that. I thought about asking for proof of his divorce to make sure he didn't lie about the marriage, but does it really matter?
And...think he's trying to distract me with talks of exclusivity right after the confrontation? Or am I being too cynical? Either way I'm not ready and wouldn't say yes, just feeling confused on what's real.
Fast Forwarding, Future Faking
Good luck to you and future happiness, with or without him. My guy keeps telling me that we're soulmates, and that he knew that we were when we met. My first cousin says that she knew she would marry her first and late husband the moment they met. She misses him still, ten years after he died.
***Used to be hit-by-a-train***
You present yourself a certain way on OLD, and there is no reason to lie about being D. You have to trust what they write as who they are, so lying, or saying it is "private" is odd. That makes no sense.
It is like the one guy that I was chatting with who listed himself as D, when he was really S. When he finally told me, he said, "Well, no one has a problem with it!"
I'd just listen to what your gut is saying….
"For whatever we lose, like a you or a me, it's always ourselves we find in the sea" ee cummings
I am not completely truthfull on my OLD profile - for a very good reason. I live in a very small town, so I list Pittsburgh as my location. This is because I once had a man send me a message that said "I know who you are and I know where you live - I'll be over".
So....it's a lie, but I'm OK with it.
Being exclusive at 1 month doesn't alarm me, but the comment about knowing you were "the one" at first sight would give me pause. Sometimes such comments are intended as hyperbole, just a clumsy way of expressing high romantic interest, but it can also indicate an intent to fast-forward the relationship, or snow you over with words. Be on alert for other indicators that he is rushing things or that comments are't really lining up with actions.
Also I'd discuss what he means by exclusive. Typically it just means you aren't dating others, but for some people exclusive carries more expectations.
I'd proceed with caution.
Would he have had the option on that site of leaving that category blank?
Are there other things that are setting off your gut?
I don't think a month is too soon to want to be exclusive, but it would be too soon for me to hear that I'm the one -- do some reading at baggagereclaim and see if anything sticks out at you!
Married: 11 years, no kids
The greater danger for most of us lies not in setting our aim too high and falling short; but in setting our aim too low, and achieving our mark. -Michelangelo
Some people aren't really sure how to navigate OLD. And they make a few missteps along the way. Wanting exclusivity at a month isn't all bad--wanting to move in together at one month is. KWIM?
I look at it this way: what is the downside. OK, he wants to be exclusive. What is the downside, and are you equipped to handle the downside? From where I sit, the upside potential outweighs the downside. But you may feel differently.
Look at intent. Know yourself. Give people a chance to show you what they are. Look at their actions--do they match their words? Look at what they say and what they do.
If I had posted all the things GDM did early on, I imagine a lot of folks would tell me to next him. But I had a strong feeling he was just sometimes wrong-footed, not calculating or manipulative.
I was right. But if I hadn't been, I was strong enough to end it, and I would have.
Unless you are sure I wouldn't agree to exclusivity. You don't have to date anyone but you are open to see. If you don't want him to date anyone else then that is different.
A month is still in the early stages you are never going to have a guarantee but time does help.
If he is honest he will wait for you to catch up to feel the way he does.
Enjoy especially if you haven't been dating. It is a self discovery process. I do agree that the never married is interesting.