User Topic: Give Xwh a b-day card from the kids?
Member # 33698
Default  Posted: 6:31 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

We have done this for the past two years. He did not do it for me this year. Do I:

a. be the bigger person and a good example to my kids and give him a card from the kids for his birthday


b. accept that we have lost a level of cordiality with each other permanently and not do anything except encourage the kids to make something for him on their own?

I already have the card, but I'm happy to not bother with a card. I just don't know if that's right to do in terms of setting an example for my kids.

BS (Me) 39
Happily liberated!
Two DS and One DD
It matters not how strait the gate,/How charged with punishments the scroll./I am the master of my fate:/I am the captain of my soul.--"Invictus," William Ernest Henley

Posts: 3620 | Registered: Oct 2011
Member # 35229
Default  Posted: 6:43 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I don't and won't do anything for the sad clown's birthday or any event.

I personally don't subscribe to the notion that it is setting a good example for my kids to do so.

Now if they ask me to help them make a card I do - they make him, me, their friends, the cats.... cards and 'letters' all the time.

I may have reached a point where I'd piss on him if he was on fire.... eventually!!

Posts: 5609 | Registered: Apr 2012 | From: Australia
Member # 37898
Default  Posted: 7:00 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I had the same dilemma. If my children had known their mother's birthday had passed without their getting her anything (they are too young to know/remember the date), they would have been upset. So I reminded them of her birthday and helped them select a card and small gift.

It had nothing to do with her, in other words. I did it for the children.

Oh and of course after she received these she knew very well that it was I who'd gotten these. Nary a word of acknowledgment or god forbid a "Thank you."

My mantra #74: "I'm doing this for my children, I'm doing this for my children, I'm doing this for my children..."

(I do not expect she will reciprocate for my birthday and truly do not care.)

Divorced April Fool's Day 2014

Fear is the mind-killer.
Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration.
I will face my fear.
I will permit it to pass over me and through me.

Posts: 1627 | Registered: Dec 2012
Member # 32962
Default  Posted: 7:30 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I say if they are too young to make a card themselves then they are really too young to be missing out on anything and they won't remember it in the future anyway, so skip it. Once they're old enough to scribble out something that you can just put in an envelope as a happy birthday from them to her then let them make something, but I wouldn't spend my time looking at cards or the $.50 to buy one at the Dollar General store for my ex.

I say handmade from the children or nothing at all.

-betrayed almost my whole almost 15 yr marriage
-divorced since 2004

Posts: 880 | Registered: Aug 2011
Member # 37895
Default  Posted: 7:38 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I would do it. Not for him, but for your children. The high road is a good place to be - you meet some great people there.

Jemima Puddleduck is a trusting soul....
DD 1 Dec 2012; Divorced 11/13; 2 children
Me: BS (47) Him: WH (52) Her: 3 PA's
Ex bought a house, The Money Pit With Mold That Will Never Be Finished. He's living in the basement.

Posts: 726 | Registered: Dec 2012
Member # 37293
Default  Posted: 7:39 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I encourage my kids to create cards for their dad on his birthday, and if they want to purchase something little (like a candy bar, or some life savers) for him I will oblige in that way.

I don't want the same involvement as I did when we were married but think I should make it a priority to help guide my kids who are too young to have these ideas on their own, or just need some guidance.

Hope this helps.

"Taking the high road, and doing it with class."


Posts: 154 | Registered: Oct 2012
Member # 3703
Default  Posted: 9:14 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)


If the kids know about his birthday, are excited about his birthday, and ON THEIR OWN want to do something, I wouldn't talk them out of it. However, your job of helping the kids have a relationship with him is OVER. You've already done too much, well above and beyond what he deserves, and it has always bit you in the ass.

Buying him a card and gift from the kids? That's one too many shit sandwiches for one person to have to eat. And when you're done with that shit had better save that ziploc bag, even though there is leftover shit inside of it, wash it out and re-use it, because it's the environmentally right thing to do.

I'm personally not a believer in "doing it for the kids", it sends a bad message about the family that you aren't, that people get to do bad things, and get rewarded anyway. Unless the kids are begging you to help them get something for their dad, which I somewhat doubt, but you need to take yourself out of the equation. Let them take the lead. IF they are so inclined, they can make him a card.

Personally, I think he deserves nothing better than a pair of skidmark underwear preserved in a ziploc bag. Nice and ripe, too.

D-day OW#1 2/2004; R for 6 years; D-day OW#2 5/2010

Marriages that start this way, stepping over the bodies of loved ones as the giddy couple walks down the aisle, are not likely to last.

Posts: 3412 | Registered: Mar 2004 | From: NY
Member # 33698
Default  Posted: 9:34 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I think that I will remind them that their dad's birthday is tomorrow and that they should make him something to take over since it is also his weekday visitation. Otherwise, the generic card I bought for his birthday will go to someone else. Realistically, it's now the Owife's "job" to celebrate his birthday, and if she's as wonderful a mom as she and XWH think she is, then she has likely gotten him something from the kids anyway. She would do something like that-- she's all about the streamers, the decorated cake, and the show. You, know, the easy Disney parenting. She can have it.

BS (Me) 39
Happily liberated!
Two DS and One DD
It matters not how strait the gate,/How charged with punishments the scroll./I am the master of my fate:/I am the captain of my soul.--"Invictus," William Ernest Henley

Posts: 3620 | Registered: Oct 2011
Member # 36883
Default  Posted: 9:37 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I agree with the side of "do it for the kids"

You never know what the future holds and what if 10 years from now the ass is like "well, your mom never allowed you to get gifts for me" so some crazy crap.

I am sure it's happened.

I would go with your kids to get him a card or sit and help them make one.

And really - in your heart, know that its not for you, its not for him - its for the kids. Its the right thing to do for the kids.

Me: 31 MH
Him: 37 MH
New online find 6/19/14 - shit

Posts: 1767 | Registered: Sep 2012
Member # 30853
Default  Posted: 10:27 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I wouldn't give him a store bought card, but I would encourage the kids to make him something. While it blows to have to make any effort for him, it really isn't about us. It is about you raising the kids to be thoughtful people. It is you raising the kids to be respectful, even to people who don't necessarily deserve it, but are in a position where they should give it, at least for right now. It is you showing the kids that you are classy, dignified, and above their father's bullshit.

The other reason I would do it is because OWife is there now and I guarantee you she will have her kids make him/buy him something. If your kids show up with nothing, they will feel threatened and terrible that the step kids made more of an effort than they did because, despite all the shitty things he's done, he is still their dad. They still don't want her kids getting too chummy with him and stepping on their toes - they are his kids and they should be able to feel as though that won't change even with these other brats standing in the way.

I would remind them that his bd is coming up and let them make their own cards or little hand made gifts. if they want to buy him a $5 box of candy at the local drug store, let them.

This is part of that high road that can suck the life right out of you. But, it's one of those things that I think is necessary and you know that I try to remain as NC as possible and I do not and will not ever consider my ex-wh a friend or anything close to it. If he doesn't want to reciprocate, the kids will get to see just one more shining example of your class and his selfishness.

BW - me
ExWH - "that one"
D - 2011
You get what you put in, and people get what they deserve.
Hard as it may be, try to never give the OP any of your power or head space.

Posts: 2840 | Registered: Jan 2011
Member # 41181
Default  Posted: 10:35 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

How old are your kids? I am conflicted about this. My teens don't plan to give my WH anything for Christmas because they are so hurt & angry (16yo & 14yo girls). At this point it's entirely up to them.

If they are very young let them make or draw something and give it to him. Middle ages, ask what they want to do. Don't do it for them. Does he try to maintain a relationship with them? If there is no reciprocity they will realize on their own.

Boss A** B*tch
BS/52 Me, STBXpos/56, dd's 16&14
1st D-day 10/19/2013 EA/PA
2nd D-day 12/7/2013 LTA/Rendezvous
S 12/7/2013 No-fault state, 6 mo S, counting down the days.

Posts: 1271 | Registered: Oct 2013 | From: DE
Member # 39357
Default  Posted: 11:03 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

I think you have to ask yourself, "what kind of good am I actually doing for the kids if I facilitate consideration for their father's birthday?" To me, that should be something OWife facilitates when the kids are there. It's not your job to go out of your way for your xh. It really doesn't teach the kids much of anything. You can say, "kids, if you need any help making your father a card or a gift for his birthday, I'd be happy to help you." That's not only a gentle reminder but also encourages them to be thoughtful (if that's what you're after) and absolves you from taking on your past role of his wife. The kids will feel like you're there for them if they do want to create a card or gift for him while you're really doing just the bare minimum for that unappreciative, undeserving asshole.

Posts: 350 | Registered: May 2013
Member # 24210
Default  Posted: 11:19 AM, December 10th (Tuesday)

From the get-go, I let EX set the precedent...guess what? My bday(s) come and go with nothing.

So I do the same.

Once in a blue moon, DD will hand-make him something but it is not an every year thing.

I think that first 1-2 years, I did remind them it was his birthday so they should call him. I do not do this any longer.

There were a lot of things that were hard to do (or not do) those first years, but I am so glad I took the path I the years go on it makes it easier.

Eyes are useless if the mind is blind.

Posts: 2178 | Registered: May 2009 | From: Pa
Topic Posts: 13