But it's how I feel.
Right there is why you're gonna lose it all. You're not a child. Children act on their feelings. You are NOT your "feelings" and you know that feelings come & go.
Long term love in relationships waxes & wanes. OW came in on a wane & took advantage of it. You are an adult in an adult & committed relationship, it's your responsibility to constantly recreate & grow your relationship. It's work, but the payoff is TREMENDOUS in comparison to this other crap that's going on with this opportunistic OW.
You're here for help so here's a couple of 2X4's:
No.
You don't have empathy; you're unavailable & stringing OW along. You're married & you're telling your wife you like/love somebody else without just getting a D. There's no empathy in any of that.
You are STILL foggy; but you're still here, so there's hope.
You are passive aggressive; you keep "asking BW" for permission/make choices for you to avoid responsibility.
You NEVER did NC; NONE of what you described was NC. You yourself admit that your NC "breakup chat" wasn't NC. Thanks for the timeline, you DID NOT have "months of NC".
Go full out NC for YOURSELF this time-regardless of what BW does. You NEED it just to clear your head. Let's just get down to brass tacks, shall we? Can you commit to 90 days NC with OW, right here, right now?
That means you send her a proper NC letter: no "secret codes", no "maybe we can be friends someday", no "but just know I'll always have you in my heart"...none of that. Just:
OW,
I love BW, this relationship has hurt her immensely. I want my marriage. I will be deleting and blocking all communication. Any further contact with be considered harassment & legal action will be taken.
lostone209
Next, you will delete all forms of communication-phone #'s, im's, defriend, get rid of crap, stop cyber stalking...blah blah blah...
Here's what, you say you CAN'T do these things & you shouldn't be EXPECTED to give up your sentimental crap, but the fact is you are simply unwilling to give up this crap AND the crap IS crap.
Is 3 months really of TRUE NC so you can help YOURSELF too much to do for...YOURSELF? At the very least?
We're telling you what it's gonna take to get you out of the hell you've created, not just for your BW & your M, but for YOU.
You CAN do this. You WILL be happy & proud that you did. You WILL go through withdrawals as you give up your ego hit, but you will come out on the other side a great person with a sense of accomplishment.