Hi Whatnow. I don't see a stop sign, so here it goes:
I wasn't going to start an unnecessary argument with my pregnant wife over some random person. It has kind of stuck with me though, and I wonder was that the right call?
My first question for you is why would this even be a point of arguing? It made her uncomfortable. And while kudos for not responding, it sounds like your resentful about it.
My second question is why are you wondering if you made the right call? Did it make your BS feel better? If so, why are you questioning it?
I wouldn't even be worrying about friends right now. That's the very least of your problems. FWH and I have been focusing on us, as a family, hardcore for 2 years now. As a result, we're not as social as we use to be. It was a big change for FWH, but there comes a time you have to make choices. If it makes your BW anxious to have you talk/be friendly with women, well, that's life. Women friends or your wife. It *is* one or the other. There probably won't be new friends for a very long time. Like I said, we're 2 years out and FWH knows I get anxious when we meet other women in a friend setting. That's just a result of the affair.
AFAIK, I'm not allowed to use a stop-sign.
Would not say I'm resentful over how that was handled. I realize this is the new normal for us, and I'm okay with that. It kind of bothered me in that it felt like I was being micromanaged, which I don't particularly like, but like I said I realize that it is a consequence of my actions and I fully understand why my wife would be uncomfortable. It never reached the point of arguing.. I brought it up to her, and she told me that I shouldn't respond, and I didn't.
I do realize what you are saying about friends of the opposite gender, and I can absolutely see why it might seem like an issue. Just wanted to get some feedback into if the consensus was "no new friends". My assumption prior to posting was that it would be in support of a policy like that.
I think it was the right call, and a friendship or friendly conversation with some woman (or man) isn't more important than my BW. If I was to go back and the same choices were there... be friendly towards this woman and potentially hurt my wife or rebuff her and support my wife... I'd choose support my wife everytime. I just wish that sometimes it wasn't so much of an either...or. I can be friendly with someone else, and not be betraying my marriage. But fair or unfair, because of the As there is very little trust in me.
Friends' of the opposite sex?
Probably never.
Not everything was inappropriate
That's reassuring. :)
and the affairs has only made her suspicions and lack of trust worse. I do not blame her for feeling that way.
Well........that's good. :)
My wife is extremely, extremely paranoid about any sort of relationships I'm in, and I don't really operate freely.
Oh.
Bummer.
I assume we can expect JM to show up in general in the next couple of days to tell us what's really going on?
I'm trying to be honest. I'm sorry if that isn't appreciated. The truth was in the past some of my actions were probably inappropriate (especially by SI standards). What would you rather have me say?
I kind of feel like I handled this situation well. There have been times in the past where I haven't, and this time I was upfront and honest with her. I showed her the email, respected her wishes, and I'm just asking now was that the right call. I don't think my BW could really have any issues with what I did though... it was completely by the FWS book. Right?
Probably going to be same gender for a very long time, as you've proven in the past that friendships with women are an avenue to infidelity.
This is part of the new life. Doing whatever you wanted as far as having friends was part of the old you, and you've proven that the old you isn't able to be trusted. It sucks, but that is sort of the way it is.
In looking back at my own situation, even the friendships with guys would get to the point of being inappropriate as far as saying things around them that I wouldn't want my wife to hear. That's a very simple barometer. Even now, when I'm on a project or having lunch with a potential new client, or whatever, sometimes the other person/people will make some off-hand comment that I'm not comfortable with and/or that I know my BW wouldn't be happy with. So I don't respond, or I leave, or I ignore the comment(s) and try to steer the conversation back to something else. It's all part of the boundaries which are much more defined for me than they ever were for the majority of my life.
Also, there are a few (many?) people who I would like to talk with regarding events in the past. Some of them are A related events. Some are non-A related things. I've thought about it and talked to gerrygirl about it, as the result is that many of those people "don't matter anymore", sort of like that female friend from HS you mentioned in your post...why would she be sending you an email out of the blue? Are you comfortable enough with how that friendly relationship was years ago to say absolutely that given your past behavior that there was never any threat to the M? Was your BW comfortable with the friendship back in the day? Well, the reality is now that your BW doesn't feel she can trust you, even if this old friendship was absolutely not a threat to the A. Because for a long time your BW probably thought that there wasn't anything to worry about, but she was betrayed anyway.
IDK...no new friends is a safety measure to some degree. Abide by it. Respect it. Make the necessary changes within yourself to get to the point where your BW starts feeling that you've really changed and are not going to blow up her world again. It's up to you to do this, not her to provide a good enough reason to you for this restriction.
I'm not sure how to phrase this. Baxter, how long did it take for you to adopt the marriage first view genuinely? I understand what you are saying... how friendships aren't appropriate, boundaries, etc. It isn't confusing, but the way I feel is. There is a disconnect and I don't know if it is just me. On one hand, I know what the "right" thing is, and then I know what I want to do. And doing the right thing sometimes doesn't feel right.
This woman isn't the issue. It was just an example. I have no issues with not having a conversation with her... I'll live. The thing is that sort of thing has happened repeatedly in the past, and there have been times where I haven't been so gracious when my BW has had issues.
I respect you (and other FWS) for being so, uh, proactive about their marriages. But if I'm being honest, there is no way I would have exited a conversation (with same gender friends) because it reached "the point of being inappropriate as far as saying things around them that I wouldn't want my wife to hear." That seems so foreign to me... maybe I'm not that good a person? I've been around coworkers, friends, students, etc who have had normal guy conversations about women, and I've never even thought about my wife wouldn't want to hear this. I certainly in a post-A world don't chime in as much, and talk more respectfully, but I wouldn't leave the conversation. I wouldn't say my wife wouldn't want to hear this. And I worry am I supposed to be there? Because I'm not even close.
[This message edited by whatnow999 at 9:26 AM, July 21st (Sunday)]