Man... I sometimes wonder if we old farts can really give you good advice in these sort of situations. Well – I KNOW we can give good advice but it’s more of a question of whether you will heed it at all…
Let’s be clear on some issues. I don’t want you to leave this site. I really do think you need to hear both the good and the bad and what I am presenting is definitely the bad. Although I would appreciate you taking note of what I say then I’m only a voice here. Only one of 40,000. My word is not law, but the time I do think I have some experience to add to the pot here.
I don’t see “marriage” per se as a reason to recommend staying or leaving a relationship. I see the time invested, the people involved and the lives affected as the major determining factor. In your case – a 15 month marriage, part of that spend apart due to your service, no children and what you post about your WW actions… I can’t for the life of me see a sensible or logical reason for you to stay. Granted I can fully acknowledge that there might be moral or emotional reasons to stay.
So if you had a kid together, longer time together, major financial entwinement… I would definitely be presenting the “work on the marriage” angle but frankly friend… I don’t see this marriage working. I don’t see any reasonable benefits outweighing the effort, the commitment, the money, the time and the emotional pain required to give this marriage a chance.
I know that IF you decide to remain in this marriage you can raise this kid as your own. I don’t have any doubts or worries on that part of the equation.
One of the best pieces of advice offered here on SI is to take your time. Unfortunately many take that to mean don’t do anything… I prefer to see that as advice to think things over before acting on them – to evaluate the pro’s and con’s and reach a rational, calculated and reasoned decision. In your case there is one major factor that demands that you only take the time you are reasonably being offered and that is the pregnancy. IMHO you have 5-7 months to decide and that’s it. Use that time well.
OK – So let‘s start with some legal issues.
WITHOUT YOUR WIFE you need to be clear on your legal standing. I think in all states a husband is assumed the father irrespective of infidelity. There is a process AFTER birth where the paternity can be disputed. I think in most states OM has a very limited ability to dispute paternity if the husband doesn’t dispute it.
Even if OM accepts the biological paternity then you will assume financial responsibilities if you remain in this marriage and it ends in divorce after the birth. In fact – if OM accepts paternity, you remain married and you two divorce some time later you could have financial responsibility without any legal rights to visitation or custody.
Then with your wife you need legal advice regarding how to move on with the paternity, the birth, the possible intervention of OM and so on.
But then… Possibly the worst thing you could do here on SI is to accept our legal advice. What is clear IMHO is that YOU need to seek legal guidance and you need to do so without your wife. You need to be clear on the what if’s from the various scenarios.
What I look into is cold, hard facts:
Statistically just about 4/10 marriages in your age group end in divorce. So you guys were fighting an up-hill battle from day one. Infidelity is definitely one big reason people divorce (surprisingly though only the 4-5 major reasons) and add the pregnancy to that equation…
Statistically divorce rates in the military are sky high. The theory is that the unique stress placed on marriages by the uncertainty of active duty is causing this. It’s a phenomenon well known within law enforcement families (a career with a high divorce rate). [ The infidelity rate within military families and LEO however is the same as with the general public.]
Statistically a marriage that has already experienced infidelity is 4 times more likely to experience it again than a marriage that hasn’t. Basically – a person that cheats is more likely to cheat again so if you and WW don’t do the IMMENSE work required then two years from now. Keep in mind that generally people cheat because there is something missing in them. This is their reaction to get something they feel is missing. In most cases some sort of validation. No matter what YOU do then if your WW doesn’t find out what allowed her to cheat now then that urge is going to crawl back into her life.
It’s widely accepted that recovering from infidelity requires committed, joint work that takes around 2 years of IC, MC, workshops, reading, improving communications and so on. It requires that you are totally 100% willing to not live in the fact she cheated and that she is totally 100% willing to live in the fact she did. It’s an extremely tough thing to do and generally it’s better to have history and something more than emotional reasons to see it through. Plus it’s expensive if it’s to be done correctly.
I don’t see you working on these issues while or if deployed. In fact I think working on this when deployed can be extremely dangerous when your focus should be on remaining alive.
I don’t see you accepting that her decision to cheat is totally 100% her decision. This is a key issue; her past issues, her background, her being drunk, you being deployed… None of those justify her decision to cheat. Granted they might explain why she reached that point where she decided to take it that one step further but at the end of the day SHE had two options: back off or go on.
Why is this a key issue? Well – there is no way a person can prevent repeats if they don’t acknowledge the blame. If you even allow a slimmer of “well – of course I decided to have sex with OM. After all WH was deployed and I needed that emotional fix OM offered” you two are doomed to experience infidelity again.
I don’t see you truly having the truth. Experience tells me that WS never tell the truth at day one. Generally the “truth” is only clear way into reconciliation. So why did she see OM? At what point did she decide that being around him was a good idea? At what point did she get interested in him? Why? Who knew? Who supported the affair? Who encouraged her? Can she remove them all from her life?
I also think you need to frankly evaluate your emotions reg. WW. Is it a sense of losing something? Is it a sense of failure? Why do you feel so strongly about your need to save this marriage? I have seen dozens of cases here on SI where a BH does all he can to save the marriage only to realize he can’t cope with the forgiveness once the WW is onboard with R.
So what would happen if you decided a divorce made more sense?
Well - chances are you would still need to legally remove your name from the child.
Since you and WW have such a short marriage and no children then the financial aspect of divorce would be relatively simple. Possibly the pregnancy might land you with temporary support issues, but if you decide to divorce then the next step is refuting the paternity.
The emotional damage will be extensive!
But something that you will progressively get over in the next 6-18 months. Six months from now you won’t be feeling as bad. 12 months life will feel worth living. 18 months… you will be fine. And you will have the possibility of taking this experience into your next relationship and possibly founding that on a firmer base.
Just so you know where I come from: I walked in on my fiancé of nearly 4 years, of which 2 years living together, after walking in on her having sex with another man. We were only about 5 weeks from our wedding day and I ended that relationship there and then. I basically decided that since she was willing to risk it all while we were still supposedly fresh then she would be willing to risk it all later on. I decided that I had a better shot recovering from the loss and the INTENSE sorrow and pain and starting off again.
She too had all sorts of family issues. She too needed a lot of fixing, fixing I would have helped her with if she hadn’t decided her fixing-tool of choice hung between the legs of OM.
It took me 6 months before I woke up one day not remembering why I felt so numb. 12 months before I started seeing that my decision was absolutely the right one for me.
Like I said in the beginning: I don’t want you to leave this site and we will support you no matter what but I feel this angle I’m coming from needs to be heard.