Marriedman2013 - I highly respect what this site is intended for and I come here to read, learn and change. But it amazes me at the amount of judgement that comes from the Waywards here. The assumptions people make and the rocks thrown at people after reading a post about someone’s situation is shocking. We all justify our behavior including those who hurl vile under the guise of "tough love" or I have been there....I know what is best for you.
You are correct that at one level, SI is a judgement place however, I personally see that as a strength of the site and not a determent.
First and foremost, it has to be understood that each member here, including the mods, are here as a result of adultery being a life changing event in their lives. We are not, nor will we ever be, regardless of our experiences here, professional therapists, psychotherapists, psychiatrists etc. We are lay people, with varying abilities to express ourselves. And that varying communication skill is reflected in our ability to read, understand, deduce and read nuances from the written word. And its reflected in our abilities to write clearly and concisely without hyperbole and exaggeration in such a manner that everyone could readily grasp our intent, never mind the content.
Each of us here comes from our own background and the circumstance of our particular A so how could we not be guilty of the BTDT phenomena? This is what a informal support group does.
The truth is that if you don’t see things the way that the crowd does, then that’s your prerogative. Just as I am entitled to disagree with anything you said. That is why the adage, of take what you need and leave the rest. This is not a touchy feely place. This is not a place of detached, analytical and clinical discourse.
This is a moderated forum for the WS to express their own personal issues. To give and receive support. And while you may control what support you offer and how that is offered, you cannot control what the other members think, feel and offer up. That’s just not how this forum works.
Moderators do and will take steps including warnings, PM messages and locking threads where appropriate but they are not our mothers and they cannot police each and every message. The filtering of messages, helpful and harmful is left to ourselves.
I firmly believe that in a majority of cases, if is seems that the thread respondents are united in consensus and a particular message is being preached, that it would behove the member to take another look at what was written and said, in order to see if perhaps there is a point to the dissent. Perhaps, it may be helpful if both sides consider the following quote.
wincings_sparkle - If it hurts, it is something worth looking at. If it makes you angry, it is something worth looking at. If it makes you cry, it is something worth looking at.
Most if not all of us came here with poor interpersonal and communication skills. Hell, for a lot of us, the lacks of those skills were instrumental in the choices and decisions that eventually lead us to SI as the WS in the first place. That realization would seemingly be obvious to anyone here but in fact, at times, members here are held to a standard that is way beyond us.
Again it cannot be said often enough, we are not a professional counselling service and so, the quality of advice that we offer is very much conditional on the self-growth of the members responding to a post and that at times, the feelings and thoughts expressed are directly in proportion to the pain and hurt experienced by the members in their own journeys.
Marriedman2013 - It’s unfortunate because, I think many people could benefit from this site but are shunned away because they don’t see the light as others do.
Many people have benefited from this site. In fact, the protected WS forum here, which provides a safe place for the WS community to ask for and get support is one of the main reasons that SI is one of, if not the most respected infidelity sites on the net.
Yes, some members do leave and yes, some are even asked to leave but from my own experience, there are more WS who come here after they had even worse experiences on other sites. Other sites which I have visited ranged from very to extremely hostile to the WS. Finding SI and its dedicated WS forum was a life saver for me.
I would hope that you stay here. Yes, some posts may rub you wrong and irate you but for everyone that does, there should be 99 more that offer some support, advice or message that can be helpful for your healing journey.
HUFI
We can easily forgive a child who is afraid of the dark; the real tragedy of life is when men are afraid of the light – Plato