where did I make my wife the victim? Re-read the post.
OK. I reread it. Everything you write about your W paints her as a victim of circumstance, but how about this sentence as a distillation?
She didn’t want to, was too naïve to, or incapably of warding them all off.
She's too naive? She was incapable of warding them off? Consider those concepts. If she's an adult woman and is that naive or if she can't say 'No,' she's a Victim. Or she's an adult woman who made a choice to cheat.
I urge you to read about the Drama Triangle. Karpmandramatriangle.com (citation OKed by mod) is a good place to start.
I posted here for encouragement on a very difficult journey I am going to attempt.
The thing is, your post pretty much says that you won't succeed unless you change your approach.
I agree that your W may be a good person who makes horrible choices. I agree that she can redeem herself. I agree that you can make a great M.
But that requires both of you to change.
Your W didn't cheat because of M problems. MC treats Ms. MC is not your solution.
Your W needs to change her internal justifications for drinking too much and for cheating into internal prohibitions. She needs to change herself from cheater to good partner. That's hard work, and she clearly can't do it on her own. IMO, she needs a good therapist.
You need to change, too. You need to learn to keep yourself out of Drama Triangles in which your W is the Victim, with some Persecutor on the side, and you're the Rescuer, with some Persecutor on the side.
R is possible, if the partners change. R is possible, if the partners step up authentically and put themselves out there, on the line. R is possible, but it requires risking the end of the M.
But ... R is not a reasonable goal at this point.
You need to recover first. You heal you. Your W heals herself. If you do that and both decide you want to stay together, then R becomes a reasonable goal.
But heal yourself first. Don't swallow being betrayed. Process the grief, fear, anger, and shame. Don't stuff them inside your body.
My W was damaged; she's a CSA survivor. During her A I had loved her for 45 years. 45 years of loving her with everything I had, and she took in only a little bit of it.
After fucking up our M, she started to tear herself down and rebuild. I felt the damned feelings and let them go. We both worked to tear the M down and rebuild it - essentially the same ingredients, but different attitudes towards ourselves and towards each other.
We did it. You can, too. The thing is, you need to learn to stay out of Drama Triangles in addition to processing your feelings. Drama Triangles is where co-dependent people live, so I've just used different words to say you need to get yourself out of co-d. I had done enough therapy pre-A, so I didn't have to do that work to recover from being betrayed. I think you do.
I'm not saying your path is easy. It's very difficult. But you can navigate it, and despite the pain, you will be a lot happier if you do the work than if you don't.
So ... IMO you're on a wrong path, Divided. You can find and follow a right path. If you do, you'll get all the encouragement you want.