Wonderful post, Maryann.
I want to echo what she wrote about wayward repainting and build on it a little bit. I was molested by an adult neighbor as a kid. I haven't quite been able to figure out how old I was, but I was definitely preadolescent. I was also old enough to be groomed into feeling that I was special because of the sexual attention he gave me in private. It made me feel powerful, and that was valuable to me as a precocious kid who hated being treated like a child. He made me feel like an equal in a world of people who condescended to me. Sometimes, I would even hang out hoping that he would initiate something. If I had been an adult, it would have been flirting.
I spent most of my adult life believing that I was not a victim, that it was offensive to call myself a victim when there were real CSA victims who were fucked up by violent coercion. I did not see until recently how the experience really did fuck me up mentally and emotionally, because I was too young to understand that I was acting above my pay grade. However, the adult man did know it. He knew that I was not a gray area -- no jurisdiction lets you act in a sexual way with an 8-year-old -- but he wanted what he wanted. He may have told himself lies about why what he did was mitigated by how I behaved, but if so, I'll never know.
You have two kinds of sexual abuse in your past, which must make the contrast feel even more stark. In the first, it sounds like you were violently raped by strangers, an experience that deeply traumatized you. In the second, there was a man with knight in shining armor tendencies who tried to get you away from a potentially lethal situation. You see him as completely different, more your victim than the reverse. It's not nearly so black and white.
Part of what I took away from my CSA was that my sexuality made me feel powerful. To admit that I was vulnerable and victimized, when I saw myself as having the upper hand, was really hard for me. I did some really awful things while chasing that sense of sexual power. I refused to see the way the OM lied to me and manipulated me, because doing so would have meant admitting that the A was wrong and sick and that he had had power over me. And that wasn't the narrative I wanted; what I wanted to believe was that he was kind and I was irresistible, a siren who made him want me against his better judgment. In short, I made him the man down the street, only this time, I was an adult who should have known better.
I love what Maryann said. Just because he was wrong doesn't mean you were right, but also, just because you were wrong doesn't mean he was right. He's painting himself as the steady, reliable, mature adult as a foil to your permanently adolescent shitshow. The shitshow may be accurate, and you have a lot of work to do to own it, but a steady, mature adult does not fuck a teenage addict, no matter what inducements she offers. She is not in a position to give informed consent to anything.
I am so sorry about what happened to you at 14. I hope that your healing will help you cope with that, at long last. I also hope that both you and your H will acknowledge that the origins of your relationship were deeply problematic on both sides, and that he has work to do in facing his role as a perpetrator as well as as a BH.
[This message edited by BraveSirRobin at 11:34 AM, December 11th (Wednesday)]