Infidelity is a horrible trauma under any circumstances, and yes, this is most definitely infidelity. It is always a trauma for the whole family no matter what anyone says. It is an attack on the family unit.
But in your case, the trauma has been visited on your entire extended family which complicates and magnifies everything.
You’ve gotten great advice already. I’ll just add that in your situation, I would not be able to see any way to consider staying with him. He didn’t have a consensual affair. He sexually assaulted your niece. There is no question about it. She had to ward him off more than once. He doesn’t contest that.
This is its own horrible trauma that will affect her for likely the rest of her life. She will question whether she can trust anyone. She will likely need extensive counseling to have normal trusting sexual relationships.
Have you considered how even thinking about taking him back would affect her, a very young woman victimized by a close relative that she trusted? Her parents? Your extended family? Sadly, he has traumatized everyone in a way that ripples throughout your family. Like you are questioning how you didn’t know, her parents and siblings may be blaming themselves for not having seen signs (that may not have even been there to see). They are likely thinking back over past interactions between them trying to remember anything they missed.
Allowing him back into your life would mean exposing all of them, including his victim, to the constant reminder and trigger of his presence. It might also cost you relationships with some of them—and you need your family more than ever right now and into the future. They might feel horrified that you would stay with someone who could do such harm and behave in such a vilely inappropriate ways with one of the children of the family.
Your sons are right, sadly. He has forfeited his right to be a part of this family unit by violating a member of it and betraying everyone in it. This compounds the nuclear family trauma of infidelity that shatters the core family in any event. He has shattered everyone.
I’m so sorry for your whole family. I hope that you are all taking care of each other and trying to find a way forward to deal with his sweeping betrayal.
His counselor should not be communicating with you and certainly shouldn’t be putting pressure on you to make a decision. His petty excuses and grievances that he is using as a pretext for violating your niece as well as your family unit show how seriously screwed up he is and how much serious therapy he needs to be a safe human being for anyone. This is his problem. But it doesn’t sound like he has a counselor who is in any way prepared to hold his feet to the fire and deal with all of his issues.
Your therapist is right—reconciliation is an extremely rough road under any circumstances. But this is so much more. But she is using the language of sexual predation to talk about him. This is appropriate, unlike what his counselor seems to be doing. So can you see your way to having any interest at all in a man who has betrayed you horrible and is also a sexual predator and also preyed on a child who is like your own?
For what it’s worth, I think you’re on the right track. You and your kids and your whole family will likely begin the long road to healing and recovery much more easily if you don’t have to deal with his presence as a constant trigger of all the trauma he’s left in his wake and without having to deal with worrying about his predatory behavior, his self-justifying excuses, and the long road he has to figuring out how he could behave like this. He obviously has a seriously aberrant idea of his own sexual entitlement that extends beyond his wife to women in general.
Hugs to you, coolchip. I’m so sorry for what you’re going through. Like all trauma, the only way through the trauma of betrayal is through. One step at a time.
[This message edited by NowWhat106 at 7:51 AM, Sunday, January 4th]