NaiveAgain, that is a wonderful relationship story.
I do think that OLD is very artificial. The only part that does kinda match with organic dating is there generally has to be at least basic physical attraction.
IRL, you see someone, but it is how they move, how they are dressed, how they speak, maybe how they are treating another person. You may find that someone that was a 6 on your "scale" turns into a 9 once you get to know them.
When I was young (college), I met most guys either on campus, at a party where he was a friend of a fried, or at a bar…with a friend of a friend. BUT, I was once picked up on the beach (I was vacationing with my family…that was a brave guy!) and once out shopping with a friend. I met my ex at a wedding.
^^^In each of those scenarios, we got to size each other up physically before speaking. There IS some physical component to dating, which is why many of us who met organically the first "go round" find OLD so uncomfortable. But, the younger generations view OLD as THE way to meet people.
There were always creeps and slim balls out there. No matter what, it is a roll of the dice. I can remember working retail fresh out of college, and was helping a man buy socks. I thought he was a nice man, about my father's age or older. Imagine my surprise when he called the store a few hours later and asked me out.
There are no hard/fast rules to dating. But, by far, I am contacted the most by men at least 10 years my senior. Based on age and photos, I'm not going to give them a shot. Plus, I had kids kinda late, so a man 10 years older than me has kids in college, while mine are still in elementary school. We are in very different places in life.
Interesting thread.