sotf, I agree with all you said.
He did initially go back to beg her back.
He started to tell her "I need space, we need to slow down, etc" and realized those were all the things I'd been telling him and it threw him for a loop.
She told him she was willing to work on things (or at least this is what he tells me, but as I've said before he's a known liar lol) and started listed all the things he would need to do: full transparency, phone, email passwords, etc.
All the things I'd said to him.
He said he asked himself what I had asked him...why would he do that work for her when he's known her 3 months, and been married to me 17 years.
One thing I've told him repeatedly through this was that he needed time to think on his own. He is terrified to be alone and that drives a lot of his actions. Times we tried to come back together and work on things he was always at my side. I told him it is not my job to keep her off your mind. I am not a replacement or a safety net.
Today when we talked he said he's not saying divorce isn't the best answer, but that he owes me the hard work and committment and he's willing to jump through my hoops and give me all the space I need to show me that.(He had demanded I move back in the house to work on us and when I refused he was irate. Like I said, he is terrified of being alone. He said I am not begging you, I just needed to say that.
I told him "I know you feel like you've turned a corner, but I thought you had done that several times already. I already emailed the lawyer for an appointment and I am not sure this changes anything. I know I can commit 100% to being divorced, but I looking at working on us...I don't know right now if I can do that."
I told him I didn't want to talk to him until at least Monday unless it was about the boys. He said that was fine (first time he's ever said that) and that he hoped I had a good day and thanked me for hearing him out.
He did also apologize for some of his previous bad behaviour and said he was still being selfish and that he had no right to be mad or upset with me, that this was all his fault and he took the blame for everything.
Maybe he's been trolling to see what words to use? Lol.
I am going to spend my weekend with the boys and relax without this on my mind.
I am in a calm stat right now and although very sad about the situation, I don't have much energy to invest in it.