Confused, as to your question of if it is better to tell, or rather to just become a better spouse without telling and to work on the marriage without disclosure...I'm going to try to just discuss that.
You can read my profile for more details, but in short, my husband had multiple affairs. Four AP's in total with various degrees.
AP#1 was three times of sex, one oral sex and no emotions. She hooked him up with AP#2 after she moved away.
AP#2 was a LTA of over 2 years in which she loved him and wanted to have his baby. He ended it when she told him that. However they still worked together a few more months, and then after she moved she tried to continue with an EA.
AP#3 was his most emotional attachment. He did not have sex with her, but had been physical in other ways. They both said I love you.
AP#4 was a one night make out session during false R.
So...this went on for a period of 5 years. I knew NOTHING about AP#1 or AP#2. All I knew was that my husband became very emotionally unavailable. He emotionally and at times, physically abandoned me during those times. I was very ill health wise, and I had very little support from him.
He was angry, sullen, and detached from me and our children. I kept trying to be a better wife in hopes it would help our marriage. I tried to do things to help us get closer both just in marriage and our family. It didn't work.
I felt isolated and rejected, but I had no idea why. We did have sex, but there was no emotion. We were not connected at all. He used me as a sexual release, not as a loving wife.
I knew there was something very wrong with our marriage, but I didn't know what. I begged for him to go to marriage counseling with me, he refused. So I went to IC myself. Tried to fix ME because I thought *I* was the problem. It didn't help our marriage even though it helped me to a degree.
Again, during this time, I was very ill. I had a very intensive surgery a few months before DDay1. He had just ended things with AP#2 and right after he went back to work after helping me after my surgery, he began to pursue AP#3. I then had a very scary breast biopsy, and I can remember him being so cold during that time.
I ended up finding out about AP#3. I confronted him with proof, he admitted only what he had to. I was devastated. I thought it was due to my health issues. He swore to me, it had ONLY been AP#3, no one else. But in my gut...I knew there was more, again however, I didn't know WHAT.
We went to therapy, I questioned and questioned. He continued to lie. We were in a false R for a year. It was one of the worst R's now that I look back. I kept trying to FEEL like we were making progress, but we weren't. Because there were still lies between us, he still had a huge wall between us, because he didn't want me to know about the others. He was still very angry and volatile.
Then DDay#2 happened. He was fired for sexual harassment because he was trying to pursue someone else.
You see, because he didn't disclose, he couldn't truly work on himself and truly fix himself. Because he was still lying. And, he was trying to find a way to fill a hole in him, but couldn't with me, because he couldn't be honest with me.
DDay#2 was his bottom. I found out about the other three AP's. You want to talk about shock? Yeah. It was horrific. I felt like that year of false R was such a slap in the face to me. He had been lying to me and our therapist for a year.
As much as the affairs hurt me, what hurt more, was the lies. It took a few months for him to GET it and stop the TT, but when we did, that is when I began to finally heal and then when we could FINALLY start working on our marriage.
My point is after all this verbal vomit is this...If I had never found out about any of this? Our marriage would have never been able to be fixed. Never. A marriage can not be mended when there are secrets and lies between spouses. The BS knows there is something wrong. We may not know WHAT is wrong, but we know that there is something VERY VERY wrong. We can't fix it because we don't know how, because we don't know what the actual problem is, only the WS does.
When everything did finally come out? Yes, I was beyond hurt, angry, devastated. However? It was also a relief. To know that I wasn't crazy. To know that there was a true real reason all along.
Once I had all the puzzle pieces together, then I was able to make a decision about our future. Prior to that, I couldn't, because huge pieces were missing and only he was making the decisions FOR me.
Most people, out of the thousands of stories and posts I've read in the past 2 1/2 years since my first dday have said, it isn't the affair that breaks a marriage, but rather the lies.
I will also say, for me, it would have been better had he confessed instead of me finding out everything. It would have been FAR FAR better had he confessed to the others as well at DDay#1 instead of having a second DDay.
I commend you for sticking with us in this forum. I know it isn't easy, but you have wise people here. They truly are vested in trying to help others along this journey. I am amazed by many of the WS here who have truly changed their lives and become authentic and honest in their marriages.
If I can advise you this...when you do confess to your husband, please do not lie, minimize or try to protect him. Tell him everything and answer any question he has. I would also suggest you write out a DETAILED timeline before hand and keep it safe. After you tell him, give it to him and tell him to read it when he's ready and that you will answer everything he needs to know.
Good luck, you are very strong.