YHGTBKM,
I have been thinking of your situation, and my heart goes out to you. Your wife has put you and your daughter in a lousy situation. She lied to you for months, and even lied to your daughter about having an affair. Is there really any kind of “explanation” that can make betrayal like that alright?
I am not saying that to cause trouble. I say it because it is exactly the dilemma I faced. I had a set of basic values and expectations of myself and my partner. They were, and are, hard-wired into me. In the aftermath of infidelity, I found myself struggling to compromise all of those values and bend them into a warped pretzel so that my partner and her actions could somehow become “acceptable” and make it possible for me to continue having any kind of meaningful relationship with her. In the end, I just couldn’t do it. I got so tired of trying to restructure all of my values and needs for honesty, openness, respect, and genuine love that I realised I would have to become someone that I wasn’t just to accommodate someone who had crapped all over me. So I stopped trying, and I parted company with someone I thought I was going to spend the rest of my life with. It was painful, but it was the best thing to do, because we parted on relatively good terms. Had I dragged it out much longer, I don’t think we could have parted that way, because we kept arguing, and I just could not trust her any more. It preyed on my mind, and the doubt that she had introduced into the relationship became a barrier between us that never changed. Weirdly, it actually seemed to grow bigger as we tried to reconcile, rather than reducing.
My problem was not 'forgiving' a particular incident that happened on a particular day. When I focused at that level, I found that I could almost sympathise, and think, "Well, she's only human, she was flattered by 'x', she was excited by 'y'", and so on. It may hurt, but we have to accept that our 'significant others' (these terms drive me nuts) are only human, and as such, they are as fallible and flawed as we are. But while I could semi-forgive/accept individual incidents (as horrible and hurtful as they were), what I could not make myself accept was the underlying principle that she let herself do that stuff. That she felt 'free' to indulge herself while she was in what was supposed to be an important relationship with me. That was revealing about her, and what she thought of me. I finally understood that whatever she felt for me, it was not the 'true' kind of love that makes a person think of their partner 24/7, and protect them. That her idea of what 'love' was did not match mine.
Thankfully, there were no kids to witness the arguments as the relationship crumbled after the trust had gone. I have always had a pragmatic outlook on life, and the old saying about, “If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, flies like a duck…” applied to my feelings about my partner after she cheated. If she walks like a cheat, lies like a cheat, acts like a cheat…I just could not get past what she had revealed about herself by cheating. She kept apologising, and I do believe she was genuinely sorry about hurting me, but she was no longer the person I thought she was when we got together. I knew what she was capable of, and no words could undo what she had done. Parting was all we could do.
And it worked out alright. We are still in touch occasionally, and I now have someone new in my life that I love and trust. Had I stayed with my ex, I never would have had that again, and the whole thing made me understand how much I need honesty, trust, and love in a meaningful relationship. I found that without those elements, I was just going through the motions, and life is too short to waste doing that.
My reason for writing this is to describe the issues that I faced in trying to reconcile, because for the sake of all concerned, you should not attempt it if your gut tells you it is not likely to work. It would make things even worse for your daughter to have her hopes raised, thinking everything could go back to how it was, only to find that it cannot happen.
What you have to keep in mind is that you are not the ‘bad guy’ here. You have questioned whether you have been too ‘harsh’. That will always be a matter of opinion, there is no right answer to that. There may be some who say you were, and others who say you should have thrown your wife out on the street the second you found out what she was doing. My take on it is that you did what felt right to you at a time when someone put you into a situation that was alien to you and not of your making. Ultimately, we have to be true to ourselves and trust ourselves and our judgement, particularly if we find we cannot trust someone close to us.
You are an intelligent and compassionate man, and you will be doing a lot of soul-searching and thinking about what is best for your future and your daughter’s future. That may be attempting reconciliation, or parting from your wife and co-parenting. Neither path is smooth, but people do make them work.
I wish you well as you work through this difficult time. Trust your gut; it will tell you what is right for you.
[This message edited by M1965 at 4:30 AM, May 15th (Monday)]