So she says that you can show me love by showing more attention and care then him;
So she has cheated on you TWICE by having two affairs and she wants to set herself up as the "prize"? Why would you want to win her back? She has shown that she does not love or respect you and her morals are not sufficient to keep her from having affairs. She is asking you to play the "pick me" game.
If she denies an affair, just please, do not let her insult your intelligence. What she has been doing is denying, lying, and gaslighting you.
She should compete for YOU. She needs to fix herself and then have her fixed, new self compete against her former broken self by comparison. If she can not win that competition convincingly (to you), then she loses.
Is it possible to love her even if the other guy is there?
No. She is infatuated with the other guy. She has put him on a pedestal and has created a fantasy life with him. You can not compete with her fantasy. You are the provider for her financial stability. Her emotions are with him. If you are to remain a couple, she has to eliminate him from her life FOREVER.
He has a great emotional connection with her, can i break through the barrier.
NO. You can not do anything except to state to her that she can have him in her life as she pleases, but not as your wife. She has to decide, on her own, that she is broken, needs to fix herself, and become the loving, faithful (at least in the future) wife that you deserve. If she chooses to stay with you, you then need to watch her actions for over a long period of time until you are certain that you can trust her to not betray you again. You need to tell her, and mean it wholeheartedly, that if she ever shows any infidelity again, you will separate/divorce from her without further discussions. You are not living in India, but Canada. She may have been corrupted, or emancipated depending upon your perspective, by Western cultural norms, while you, and your families, are still operating on your traditional norms. Both of you must agree upon which norms will be adopted for your relationship, and then proceed in life adhering to those mutually chosen norms. In the West, although the stigma of divorce is not as harsh, it is still totally up to the individual to decide whether or not to be polyamorous or to have an open marriage. You get to decide what is acceptable.
She truly believes in the concept and has access to this forum now; so, explain it away; and thanks for your support so far.
You are asking for an "appeal to authority' to convince your wife of her infidelity, even if only an emotional affair, minimization, denials, lying, disrespect and betrayal. You do not have to appeal to authority. You only need to know what is, or is not, acceptable behavior for yourself. Then you make the call. You may divorce for "irreconcilable differences." "I can not stand, or put up with, you or your boyfriend" qualifies.
If she is not deliberately gaslighting you, she is caught up so much in her bullshit that she is toxic and unrepairable. She has not reflected on your feelings, desires, happiness, so I sincerely doubt she is going to give a ounce of credence to what I post. I am posting this as simply a statement of the obvious and the facts of the matter. If she "gets it," great. If not, she is still wrong and she is not anyone's "prize".
I suggest that you separate from your wife and, as I posted before, send her to stay with her mother or with family in India. DNA test your baby. The other guy's interest in the baby and your wife's desire to have him involved in the baby's party decorations is a "red flag", or concerning development which begs for clarification. It seems odd and inappropriate.
If divorce is not realistic, then separation may be your best alternative.
This woman has "fired" you from the role of husband. You have been reduced to a "meal ticket", or perhaps you are just cultural baggage since divorce is frowned upon in your culture.
Times are changing in the Indian culture. I found this BBC item interesting:
Over time, the traditional joint family has given way to nuclear families in cities and towns; and more and more women are going to work or setting up their own businesses. Many urban women no longer have to depend on their spouses for financial security, men are sharing household chores; and gender equations are slowly changing.
Do not let your wife behave like she is single while married to you. Tell her to reflect on her marriage and family and decide what is important to her. If she decides that the "other guy" is more important to her than you, her marriage, and her family, divorce her. I am sure that there are many Canadian women who will treat you much better than she has (pretty obvious since she has set the bar so low).
Good luck.
Me, I would just divorce her. I really do not see how anyone could stand her for a second longer given how horrible she has treated you by openly, flauntingly having two immoral (IMHO) affairs. But, that may not be you. Just understand why you would want to saddle yourself for the rest of your life with such a poor example of a wife. Cultural biases, or not, that is a lifetime sentence for bad acts that SHE did, not YOU. You have done nothing to disgrace yourself (except for tolerating her bad behavior for so long).
[This message edited by PassThis at 2:26 PM, February 11th (Tuesday)]