Back to you, what have you been doing to work through your own issues? Have you been 100% honest with him. To be fair, I have a hard time believing a 4 and a half year affair only included oral sex. Affairs escalate and that’s a long time. Why didn’t you go further? What held you both back? Did he pressure you? Why was that a bridge you wouldn’t cross, but the oral sex was okay? Did he perform oral sex on you too? How did you feel about him? Did you love him? How do you feel about him now? How are your interactions with your BH?
Your posts seem very clinical and distanced.
I have looked at your post several times and for a reason I couldn't put a finger on, didn't reply to it. I think Mrs. Walloped put her finger on it for me.
One, I also have a hard time believing your story. I know truth can be stranger than fiction, but I had a two month affair with someone who lived over a thousand miles away from me and I still managed to have sex with the AP. The other thing that makes that seem strange is your AP blew through a DDAY and you all resumed the affair. I can only imagine that intensified and solidified the affair further. Again, anything is possible but it's extremely rare and unusual so it's not going to be easily accepted.
I also wondered about feelings. I had a hard time shutting my feelings off after two months, did you believe you were in love with this man?
The second thing that is a bit off-putting is the clinical sounding part, but that I at least understand. I don't think it's uncommon for new WS's to arrive here numb. I numbed myself to my feelings before the affair, and then numbed myself by having an affair, and then numbed myself more because I couldn't deal with the aftermath.
When we numb the bad, we numb all our feelings. And, I couldn't figure out how to get out of that after DDAY. It makes us less present, less empathetic.
Maybe I am projecting but do you feel that you are having trouble really being in your heart on things?
I will also say I am never a fan of both people being on here in the early days after DDAY. There is a tendency for a lot of people to choose sides and use things one said against the other. I have actually seen people carry over things that weren't even said. It's almost like the site becomes a third party to your relationship. I have seen some WW's get help by doing private messaging with other WW's. There are a few of us that our spouse joined after we did but it was after the roller-coaster period that is after dday.
It's up to you of course how to use the site, and so far I don't think it's gone so horribly, but I feel like I would be wrong for not stating that I have seen this get very ugly. This in my opinion is correct:
but should we not both be looking at points of view from people as guidance and not a dictation of what is the appropriate course of action to attempt to reconcile?
What is right for some is not right for all. And, just because people recommend it or strongly feel that its needed doesn't mean it's right for the two people involved.
BUT, I will say in order to reconcile, especially in light of an affair that lasted for so long, it's going to be very hard for your husband to feel like he knows everything he needs to know. This will be important for his healing. R is a long hard thing to go through, and I believe all the pain is in the details. Until they are all uncovered, and the WS can understand how each detail is a cut, the relationship will not heal.
The BS can heal on his own whether it's R or D, but if you want R some of the things people recommend have really good reasons behind it. Every time the WS is found to be lying, it's like dday all over again, and all the work done before it becomes washed out. Everything has to start again. So, if you go a whole year, and then he finds out that you lied about something major (like sex) then the timer starts all over again, trust is even harder to ever build back, and your chances for R have gone down significantly.
I point this out because a lot of times the lying is justified as "protecting the BS" but it actually ends up doing far more damage than the affair itself.