FWL, you are beginning to really *see* your WH.
If it's any consolation to you, I also spent a kabillion of my life-hours having the same types of circular and stupid conversations with stbx that you are having with your WH. And hindsight being 20/20, it really was 9.99/10 kabillion's too many.
For whatever reason (FOO, personality disorder, just a dick, whatever), he is a self-serving cheater and he believes that he deserves a different set of 'rules' than the rest of the people in the world.
Your WH is a blamer and he has a *victim* mentality. You are not going to win this war. You can't. Unless you are willing to live the rest of your life in a 'not-right' relationship.
Here's a little recent backstory (since it isn't in my profile):
Stbx cheated again a little over 3 years after Dday. Not a big surprise, really, since he had been remorseless throughout that 3 years. I got 'snowed' by his "I'm 100% committed to YOU, Gonna" bullshit.....which is why I was still giving him 'chances'. I ignored his actions and chose to trust his words. My bad. Anyway. He confessed because OW was going to tell me (which she did end up doing). He refused to be honest and transparent, so I filed for D. One month later he recontacted that OW. According to him it was to find out why she was acting so 'crazy' (gee, I wonder
). 3 weeks after that...he was chasing some chick around a convention in Vegas trying to get her to sleep with him. A month after THAT he took up with yet ANOTHER OW.
The whole time he was engaging in these shenanigans, he was insisting that HE didn't want the divorce and that the demise of our family was *my* doing.
And he was the exact same type of twisty-talker that your WH is. He throws a bunch of smoke-bombs into the conversation so that you end up having some conversation that really amounts to jack-shit. Lather, rinse, repeat.
But break it down and look at it.
WS cheated and 'blew up' the marriage.
BS says 'fuck this' and separation/divorce ensues. Even if BS is still engaging in hours of explanatory-type conversations. You know the ones that you have with an 8-year old, right? Cheating is wrong. Marriage is made up of 2 people. Yada, yada.
First of all. WHY should these very basic concepts have to be 'explained' to a grown-ass adult? If that person doesn't *get it* by now....well, the odds are that they won't unless they really, really want to because that is just basic *Human 101*.
Secondly, how does it make any sense for a WS that wants to 'save' the marriage and is separated/being divorced due to their cheating.....to continue in wayward behaviors? And then to use the "well YOU don't want to be with me, so *I'm* going to date* as a justification? The answer is that it DOESN'T make any sense. It's obfuscation.
FWL, your WH tells you to 'release your fear'. Really? Why should you do that? He's still wayward. He hasn't done jack-shit to *earn* his way back into the fold. And yet he expects YOU to make this right? He expects YOU to just *be there* at <whatever> time he 'decides' to choose 'you'?
I hate seeing how your WH is treating you. But it's only because I've BTDT and heard all of the same things and I know how it ended for 'me'. I am still the one that is blamed for the end of the marriage. I am getting the divorce that *I* wanted and am now the 'greedy' wife that wants to suck him dry.
According to stbx, I am judgmental and unforgiving. I received a text the other night that said "you are truly a different person. And that is not a good thing." NC be damned...I responded with "me being 'different' is most certainly a good thing. That wouldn't be a problem if you weren't the *same*."
Detach, honey.