Abbondad:
I have been following your story now for literally months on end now and I want you to know how much I feel your pain and I am truly empathetic towards anyone going through a divorce. The reason I am replying is in regards to your chair, as you are SO CLOSE TO THE END here I don't want you to lose sight of the goal.
-- wavy lines --
11 years ago I started a divorce from a woman who had gone insane. I was with her half my life at that point and couldn't believe that she had cheated on me multiple times in the past and was in the middle of an emotional affair with one of my good friends! I will avoid all the scandalous details but I wanted to tell you this.
I filed for divorce literally like a few days before New Years of 2003. It took until JULY 2005 to finalize. Why?
She wanted the house, the 401ks, the cars, all our dogs, and everything in it. She was in school to be a paralegal and made my life hell with the things she would do. We would schedule mediation and she wouldn't show. We would agree on things and get them down on paper and suddenly she would change her mind. I had the strength to fight at first, but after a while I looked at the calendar and I was like, what the hell, when is it going to be time to restart my life?
At the end, I gave her like 1/3 of my 401k, half the house, the better car, most of the contents of the house, all of our dogs (including *MY* dog that I had since she was a puppy) primarily because I didn't want to keep this up anymore. At that point, I didn't feel like I was "winning" anything by having this drag out. I actually felt like it was a "win" to be in that courtroom, AT LAST, and listening to the judge grant me my dissolution of marriage.
-- /wavy lines --
I tell you this story not because I am telling you that I think you should just give up your chair. You know as well as I do that even if you said, sure, have the chair, let's sign the paper, and be done with it, that she could easily take this and ask for additional things. I totally relent that.
But - and I know this probably goes against much of the advice you are receiving here - in my case, I had such a terrible divorce that I realized, did I really want to keep anything from that marriage, anyway? I fought so hard to keep my couch because it was my first "real" piece of furniture when I had a great job and I could treat myself to something nice. A symbol of success. After the divorce and I got an apartment again, I put the couch in there and realized it didn't fit in my life anymore. Within a week I dragged it to the dumpster and picked up something cheap from IKEA to hold my living room over.
I know the chair symbolizes something great to you - it was a gift from your children on Father's Day. Even your kids call it, "Daddy's Chair." I'm sure when you sit on it you feel like the King of your Castle. Those kinds of feelings are what my couch made me feel - independence, success, maybe even wealth. But once that marriage was over, I found it wasn't the same for me anymore, and in fact that couch only brought back memories that I wanted to forget.
I wish you all the best these next few days and I hope things very much go your way. I merely wanted to share my story with you because for me, getting divorced was the real win, regardless of how much or how little I could have "punished" her or continued to drag that thing out.
Oh yeah - she called me last year "out of respect" to tell me that my dog was dying and if I wanted to go see the dog put down. For a minute, I thought she was trying to extend an olive branch and accepted the offer, upon which she said I could go as long as I paid for half the fees. After all, it was my dog. I told her to pound salt (not really, I used some choice profanities, but you get the idea).