I wanted to post an update here bc this group has been so helpful and supportive. The talk about the exchange with his ex wife went as well as it possibly could have. He apologized, acknowledged that it was wrong, recognized how inappropriate that it could have sounded, and while understanding how I could have read there to be nostalgia involved, reiterated that he has only platonic feelings for her and was trying to be supportive to her during a tough time. I felt a lot better. He had really thought about it, how I felt, offered to have NC or have me see all of their texts, etc... We had a really healthy and open conversation and then spent the day reconnecting and talking. While not something I have with any ex's, I think it's good to have a positive relationship with one and I know he's a good guy and just wants the best for her.
BUT - and, of course, there's a but here. Not because of - but with - some of the time we took not really speaking - he has become somewhat hesitant about having a kid which is something we've talked about and have been on the same page about having 1.
As background, he and his ex sadly lost a baby and their marriage fell apart before they could successfully adopt. He has said from early on that he still wants to have a kid, has always wanted to be a father, and knows if he doesn't he will regret it.
He's wavered on getting remarried but now says he would marry me and wants to be with me and my DD. But he has a lot of concerns about a baby. Mainly they are financial - we live in a pricey city and recently his only living parent has become a financial burden who he will have to partly support. But also his age - 43 - is a factor as he's a huge planner and has worked hard to live very comfortably and retire at a certain age and things like traveling and continuing to take me out to nice places are very important to him. I sense that he's become comfortable in his life on his own and- even thought he's always wanted to be a father - is finding it now hard to go back to that mindset...
Obviously having a kid makes things like travel, going out, etc... more difficult. For me, having another has always been really important and I'm more than willing to sacrifice a lot for it. And, as a parent, I'm already not really placing as high of a premium on these things. I'm still young enough where I could do it, but time is a factor for me as well (I have frozen eggs so not totally panicked, and I don't think this would be my last chance).
Neither of us want to end things - we want to be together, we love each other, we communicate well and have a great relationship. He says he could "get there" but he's just worried. Which is also what he said about remarriage early on.
But, this is so hard b/c I can sense that he's now pretty hesitant and confused about this. I'm about 80% that I would walk if he definitely didn't want a kid. He is probably 50/50 at this point. I know it's not something to be pushed, but because he's always said that it's something he's wanted, I find myself trying to be patient, reassuring and supportive and sometimes I feel like I'm trying to re-convince him. And, I've been down that road w/ my XWH...I know it's not something you want to push on someone.
I just can't get a great read on how much he is just nervous, b/c, of course, it's a huge decision and everyone should be nervous. Versus, is he now telling me that we want different things?
I have considered, should I just let it go and accept that I am lucky to have someone who wants to be with us and have a family with DD and me? And, let's face it, is it MUCH easier to just have the one and then relish in our relationship, and having more freedom, time, money, traveling, etc... those things sound great to me.
I'm just not sure I'm ready to let go of having a second. I want to give him more time. But because of our ages, we just don't have that much. In my heart of hearts I think he's confused and really contemplating the reality of a baby which I get. I'm just not sure what to do at this point.