So really isn't R just settling for less then what marriage was actually intended to be?
It CAN be. Or it doesn't HAVE to be. I'll go one step further and let you know that reconciliation can set the stage for a marriage that is FAR better than it ever was... better, in fact, than you might ever experience if you go out on the market again and find someone new. Let's face it, that person probably has baggage, to.
My comments about this, as I stated in my last post, can be found on the other thread I mentioned.
If you half-ass reconciliation then you get what you put into it - a half-ass marriage. And, yes, that's not what marriage was intended to be (although that's exactly what it is for most people - infidelity or not).
What reconciliation does for you is it opens the door to creating new rules about your marriage. You have, in effect, a reset button that you're now allowed to hit. Why? Because one of the conditions of reconciliation SHOULD be that it is more accommodating of the needs of each partner. So if there are things about your marriage that you never really liked (and I don't know a single person who is getting EVERY need met) then you can now put your foot down and say, "This is how things are going to go moving forward."
Hopefully, she'll say the same to you. And as you both heal you'll realize that you're moving forward into a marriage that is FAR better than the one you had. You'll realize that she has learned from what she did and is able to make amends. And you will heal.
Or... she can't. In which case your reconciliation is bullshit and you should divorce.
The key is, of course, recognizing that you still WANT your marriage, can accurately assess if your wife is CAPABLE of doing the hard work, and, lastly, if you even care enough to try.
Reconciliation doesn't have to be "settling for less" unless you allow that to happen.