MJ
Reading your posts makes it even clearer to me that this isn’t about the sex.
I think there are two major issues you need to deal with:
Your trauma from infidelity.
Communications in the marriage.
Infidelity is possibly the biggest trauma you will encounter in life. Ignoring the trauma or trying to self-heal the trauma is not likely to work.
I am – in the strongest words possible – going to encourage YOU to get professional help. You can do this in several stages/phases:
These two you can do NOW:
Start by ensuring you are eating. Preferably eating healthy, but make sure you are consuming calories, so your body can function normally.
Exercise. Hit the gym, take walks, start jogging. Just make sure you get some physical activity, even if it’s only a 15-minute walk down the street.
Contact your doctor and ask about some mild sleeping-aids or anxiety help. Most of us are reluctant to do this, being afraid of addiction and/or dependency. But if you decide ahead of time to get the mildest ones you can and have a predetermined period (60-90 days) in mind then this can work like a crutch while you seek other more permanent treatment.
Find a good IC. Shop around. Find one that is good in marital trauma and infidelity. Possibly your IC can eventually become your MC. But start with YOU. Chances are the affair makes you depressed. You definitely show signs of PTSD. You feel imprisoned, trapped… Get some help because a good, trained professional can help you in a very short time to get out of infidelity.
I am about as confident and self-assured as they come. I walked in on my then-fiancé having sex with another man some 30 years ago. This was before the internet and online forums and SI and all that stuff but basically, I did the near-perfect 180 and detachment. I left that relationship and about 2 years later met my present wife. I was certain I had left this all behind. About 15 years into my present marriage we ran into some rough spots and frankly they were mainly my fault. I had the sense to seek IC and was quickly diagnosed with rampant PTSD. The PTSD was partially linked to experiences I had as a cop but MAINLY due to the infidelity. Once diagnosed it only took a few sessions learning coping-mechanisms to deal with it.
What I’m trying to get across is that you can leave this marriage but if you don’t do something about YOUR trauma you will simply bring it along into any future relationship you try to establish.
I see some positives in your WW actions but also a lot of negatives. Once again, I think that might boil down to communications. If she’s not seeking IC, then I don’t think her ability to become a good spouse will improve.
Comments like it only being about the sex minimize the trauma, and if she minimizes or if YOU allow her to get away with minimization then IMHO there isn’t much chance of a good marriage.
Keep in mind that you have access to a resource like this one, but she probably is doing this all on her own.
I’m going to make this suggestion regarding your marriage:
This is based on what you share that the active affair seems to be over.
Tell your wife how damaging the infidelity really is. Make it clear that it’s traumatized you and that you are far from recovering from her actions. Make it clear that divorce is still a possible outcome but that now you would want to feel assured that you had done what YOU can do to work on the marriage. Then offer a 60 to 90 day period where you both focus on IC and simply try to coexist. Basically, this period is used for both of you to get to a better place where you two as individuals are better suited to work together on the infidelity and it’s wrecking effects on your marriage.
You don’t like her last IC? Well… Start with YOU finding your own IC. Ask him/her if it’s a good idea that the same IC handle both of you and eventually becomes MC. If not then again – start by finding your IC and ask that one to recommend someone for your wife.
If you do this then also agree to spend an hour every Saturday simply evaluating if you are making progress and setting some scale on if you are closer to wanting to reconcile or divorce. No matter what that answer is then stick to the originally negotiated/offered 60-90 day period.
I am also going to encourage you to at least google divorce in your state and evaluate in an honest way it might impact you. Better still see an attorney. This isn’t done because you plan to divorce, but rather to have a better understanding of your options.