So I recognize everything everyone has said here. In fact there are a couple coworkers whom I vent too and they say the same thing. WS has posted in here once, and she is more than welcome to post in here, as I have invited her to post in here if she felt the need. She clearly is not happy about what anyone says about her and she believes that most of the people here for wrong about her.
Everything I have said here had already been discussed with her, prior to me posting. Generally I jump on here after an argument because I need to vent. So we had already talked, or more often, fight about the current topic at hand.
To me to threaten the marriage because she didn't tell me she used the elevator instead of the stairs (place of many encounters with OM2 at work) seems like its it taking a sludge hammer to an ant. I feel like the punishment in some cases is having the arguments and hitting that reset button. Maybe WS doesn't feel that way. I feel like it would be inappropriate to use D as the consequence for any and all failures to comply with the guidelines/boundaries/communication etc. Because some boundaries I consider minor, vs some more important.
I am also particular sentimental. I have been with my WS since I was 17 and I am now 33. I have spent 16 years with this person. I have spent 16 years believing that she loved me and I loved her. I spent 16 years believing she is the perfect person for me despite our differences. I spent 6 years believing we had an amazing marriage. I spent 16 years hearing about how many other couples were jealous/envious of the kind of relationship WS and I had. I do authentically believe that we have had real moments. I do not believe for a second she is the complete monster some people paint her as. I do believe we have had great moments. I believe the love is there, but I also believe her selfishness is also very important to her. I think it is the battle within her and are often conflicting each other. But during 1st year of our marriage, she had an ugly persona that reared its ugly head. The same persona that reared its head with the first time she cheated on me early on in our relationship. This persona crops up when we apparently have issues in our relationship. The first time it was "I wasn't communicating enough and we had a relationship that was only physical". Second time it was " I wasn't there physically there for her". I recognize that WS is the problem. WS has the communication issues. She refuses to talk to me about her issues. Even now I am trying to get her to talk (not be defensive, but actually just own what she has done and accept our life is no longer what I thought we had). So I have been living 16 years believing certain things, only to have been told that I was wrong about some of those things. It is not something I am able to accept so easily. Again, I felt those emotions, the love, the compassion. Especially, after we had kids. The looks she gives when she sees me playing with the kids. I believe that kind of example of those feelings are real and authentic. I don't think the whole marriage was a lie, but unfortunately some important aspects of it was.
Her explanation for the affair was simple. And I do believe it is a huge part of it. I wasn't around a whole lot due to full time school with a 3 hr round trip commute and working 22 hrs on Sat and Sun. To give my WS some credit, she did offer to financially support me after a couple months into the school program so that I would not have to work over the weekend and I could focus on school. Maybe it was a cry for me to be available, both physically and so she could spend more time with me for more than just a few hours on a friday night. My classes started the same week of our marriage ceremony and I would complete the program in 1 year. It was a specialty certification so that I would be working in the same exact field as my WS. She found someone who showered her with attention and desire. She loves that kind of affection. He provided it, while I was unable to during that year. After that year, her affair toned down. I know people don't believe it, I am not even sure I always believe it, but the sex stopped over the next 5 years until D day. It was apparently flirting and inappropriate messages (not necessary full sexting), but inappropriate still. There was still physical contact in the sense that she permitted OM2 to kiss and touch her, but WS stated nothing beyond that and WS never reciprocated. Again, I know most people won't believe that. And some days I believe it, some days I don't. If it is indeed true, I would say there is some regret in her decision to have cut back on the intensity of the affair.
She has admittedly said that she will never do it again. Parts of me believes that she has gone through the kind of hell to keep her from doing it again, but part of me believes she isn't actually as upset over all of this at the same time. I am not a particularly big risk taker. Divorce and staying are both risks to me. Divorce, with everything that comes with it, but also what happens afterward. Finding someone else to be with. Will I find anyone else etc. I would think trying to find someone around my age at this point much harder than it was 10 years ago when I was in my early 20s. But the risks of staying is of course WS continuing to do what she's been doing and possibly even cheat again. Because down the road if we have problems after healing, and she has forgotten the pain this past affair has caused, then maybe she will fall down that rabbit hole again. A lot of unknowns and uncertainties. I am making a huge change with D, while staying right now is tolerating her BS.
Am I being felt false remorse, possibly. I've considered it. Or is she really remorseful and not able to constantly think about all of this all the time? One would dictate that she is being intentional malicious vs the other where she is mentally incapable of providing me with the consistency that I seek.
I told myself I will keep taking the BS until I have reached my breaking point. Then I know I can accept D without having to look back at the marriage my WS set on fire.
[This message edited by ReceivedChaos at 9:11 PM, June 12th (Wednesday)]