If your SO has done stuff sexually with previous SOs and won't do them with you - and this bothers you - don't marry them.
...or the time they spend, or the love they show, or the $ they spend...
This is obvious to me. Unless you are in a faith or culture with prearranged marriages which you plan to respect...YOU get to choose.
I (respectfully) and strongly disagree that it is best not to discuss sexual (and other) past relationships / experiences. It may be true that my H’s past (before me) is none of my business - that is certainly true. But any man who enforces that right with me would not have me as a prospective partner.
We learn things - important things - relevant things about others by learning about their past. Represents values, choices, decision making, etc. and if there is stuff in out past that we are less than proud of, sharing that information is also very insightful.
I was married 2 times before meeting my H. I was raised fairly conservatively, and there were a couple of things in my past that troubled me, and when my H and I started getting a bit serious, I willingly shared those things with him...full disclosure. And not only for him, but also to protect myself from troubles down the road.
Retroactive shame as well as retroactive jealousy.
He did not do the same with me. So, when I learned certain things about his past, there were things that disgusted me - not sex acts as much as situations.
Dragn did the right thing (IMHO). She divulged the information. Even I don’t have any kind of moral issue with dating brothers in the situation she described. If it had been secretly at the same time, wouldn’t it be nice to know that in order to make a decision regarding her choices - her integrity? When considering an ongoing - potentially permanent relationship - with her?
But she was not cheating. She was not hiding. And she told her H. He did not reject her.
But now that he has demeaned himself by his choices, it seems instead of doing the work to heal, he is trying to diminish his actions by bringing up and “all of a sudden” looking down or using Dragn’s past - which he accepted before.
Weakness. That’s how I see it.
I have read all of this thread, and much of it makes sense. For me a lot of it boils down to Dragn’s H’s weakness. (JMHO).
I’m married to a quadriplegic. There were PLENTY of things I would have wanted to do with him sexually that were not anatomically possible. But we found plenty to do. It wasn’t his not completely functional body that turned me off. It was his choices before me, and of course the cheating after we were together.
I wish I had paid more attention and let his past weigh heavier when I was deciding to commit to him forever.
Dragon, I would tell him - I’d he dares to bring it up again - that you did the right thing by sharing the info, you did nothing “wrong”, and he needs to MAN UP and deal with his indiscretions rather than pretending to “tease” you about something he accepted from your past, to diminish what he has done.
Sorry...I guess this hit a nerve with me.