Mooney,
I feel sad for you. All the posters that replied to you here have gone through the same thing. We feel that the experience is so hard that we decided to help others navigate through this.
There is no reason to be humiliated. This is 100% on him and he should be humiliated to hurt his wife like that.
It’s very common for WS to “affair down”. The reason is that there no such things as a “high quality” AP. A person who decide to form some sort of relationship with a married man/woman is broken already (unless the person doesn’t know). So that makes you the prize.
Please talk to your sister as soon as possible.
You can’t get to his phone anymore, but to do what? Are you trying to gather more evidence or are you just hurting yourself, “painshopping”?
Remember that if his family gets hurt, it will be all his doing, it’s not you.
Now, you will need a plan to get out of infidelity. You can’t stay in your current situation.
Do you have enough evidence to confront him? I think you do but only you knows.
Talk to your sister for a plan of attack. It should go something like this:
WH, I know you have been unfaithful to me, Ihave proof. He may ask what proof, but don’t tell him. Don’t give your source of information. He will still try to deny, to “gaslight” you but you know the truth.
You tell him that he’s free to be with his girlfriend, but not as your wife. While he decides what he wants to do, you are getting out of infidelity with or without him. Don’t do the pick me dance, don’t cry, don’t beg, be firm. You sre an amazing prize and he, right now, is worthless. If he is very very lucky, you might give him the gift of reconciliation but not now.
Then move with your sister or your family. Or kick him you of the house. Tell your family and his family. Do the 180, detach from him. You will need to detach from him so you can take the best decisions without your heart influencing you too much.
Keep on posting, you have found a few hundred friends to stand behind you, here on SI!
Be ready to divorce. If he does all the right thing, maybe you can consider R, maybe you’ll divorce him anyways.
[This message edited by ShutterHappy at 5:57 AM, February 16th (Saturday)]