“his outlet for when things get tough is drinking, mine is sex. It’s just sex”. She just doesn’t fucking get it.
If her statement was rewritten as, "His coping mechanism when things get tough is a bottle of vodka. Mine is unprotected anal sex with sexual predators I know nothing about", it would put the recklessness of her actions into a clearer perspective.
There is no equivalence between you getting wasted and her betraying you and exposing both of you to STDs. Leaving aside everything else, she needs to wise up about her own health.
Her admission that she uses sex as a coping mechanism for stress suggests that it is an established pattern of behaviour for her, which may have happened before.
Certainly this...
We found that she deleted her text messages in the cloud. I was floored. Had no idea she was even capable of doing that. She covered her tracks.
...indicates that she is not an ignorant newbie when it comes to hiding the evidence of her actions. That raises the question of whether the affair you discovered is her first, or just the first that was busted.
So she agreed to let me monitor her texting.
There are two problems with this:
1) How long do you want to be a policeman within the marriage?
2) Sadly, there are far too many ways for people to communicate secretly for effective monitoring to be possible. If she knows you are monitoring texts, you can guarantee that nothing 'bad' will be said via text. In fact, if she knows you are reading her texts, they can become a way to feed you misinformation.
If the marriage is to be saved, it will require a change in her attitudes and boundaries, and to her level of commitment.
The fact that she is not on the mortgage, because she wanted to be 'free' to go whenever she wanted to, with no 'ties' suggests a resistance to commitment, and a desire to operate independently.
She lost it when you suggested the most recent family day out might be the last, and yet she feels free to step in and out of the marriage whenever it suits her.
Effectively, your wife has been operating in a one-sided open marriage without discussing or agreeing that arrangement with you. In fact, she has done the opposite, using stealth and active concealment to keep you in the dark.
She needs to figure out whether she can provide the commitment and security that you require, and whether your ideas about what you both want the marriage to be are close, or far apart.
Which raises a potential alternative to divorce; could you handle an open marriage, in which you were also free to have 'adventures'? At least there would be some honesty and equilibrium in an arrangement like that.
The deeper issue is whether your wife is capable of mustering enough honesty with herself to be able to provide it to those around her, or if self-deception has become such a vital emotional defence mechanism for her that she will not be able to abandon it.
Change is only possible if people want to change.
[This message edited by M1965 at 5:25 AM, July 27th (Saturday)]