I almost hate to bump this topic because I know you must be absolutely exhausted at this point. I've been watching it for the past days but not at a device really suitable for typing a response.
Nonetheless, the topic has already gone in the direction of the main question I wanted to ask you: Is this p/a?
It certainly sounds like it to me. You will have to ultimately decide because what changes between just an unremorseful WS and a p/a one is the payout from the behavior. They're both manipulative and crazy making but the reasons/motives are entirely different. (And how you respond to them is different as well.)
Let me start by saying something that's probably going to incite the masses: I understand Crazz's point. I also think it's valid.
That doesn't mean he's conveying it effectively.
Nor does it mean that his boundaries are good.
It just means that he may be coming from a totally honest perspective within him. Misguided? Yes. Lacking intimacy? Yes. Dishonest? Yes - but he likely isn't aware of that.
Does that help to explain any of your confusion? Your mixed feelings for the relationship? Your mixed feelings for him? If I may suggest, shelf that for now. That sense of pressure to either leave the relationship or make it better is what is causing YOU to ride the rollercoaster. If you can change your perspective from a participant to an observer, you will find your entrance and exit from the ever moving jump rope. (And since I have harped on it so, and speaking from personal experience - I assure you that this is a place you can find your own personal growth.
)
I live with a very p/a man. They're odd birds because they can be the sweetest, most thoughtful people. They can also do things that make you absolutely nuts and bring out the absolute worst in you. You will likely never have a true and deep intimacy with them. That doesn't mean NEVER...it just means that it won't be a level that you achieve. It's something you appreciate when it comes and you let go when it leaves - kind of like owning a pet butterfly. For some people that idea would be intolerable. Due to logistical circumstances that strongly encouraged me to have to accept this, I actually now feel quite enlightened by the experiences. I found more freedom by not having to strive for the ideal - something I realized that I had been doing all my life. Of course you'll have to decide that for yourself, Jrazz...but I do believe that it will come to you.
So in the interim, let's talk about how to just observe p/a behavior...
The nature of the p/a is to not take responsibility for their feelings. In fact, it doesn't even occur to them that they have any control over their feelings. They hardly can even see or understand that those feelings actually belong to them. So they do things to get you to express what they are feeling.
Think back on your most recent interactions. Did you feel almost provoked? I know that you didn't respond in the manner you would have preferred when discussing the weekend childcare. Do you feel that you were set-up? How many times do you feel Crazz's "attempts" are misguided - hey, I'm at least telling you about the female co-worker - yet internally you know that there is just no way this charming man could then be so...well, stupid. All roads lead to rome - yet none of the pieces really fit.
When you find yourself here, feeling this - this is the first sign that your strings are being pulled. This is the internal alarm to shut-down reaction systems and instead become just an observer.
Crazz: I think I'm going to work in the garage this weekend. Baby Razz will be fine.
Jrazz: Really? You must feel like you have a lot of things that need to be done.
Crazz: Well, yeah. I do. I didn't get to do it last weekend because I had to work.
(Maybe he's mad about not having time.)
Jrazz: Could you do it Sunday instead? Baby Razz and I will go to the park and you won't be interrupted at all then.
Crazz: No. I want to do it on Saturday. What's wrong with Saturday? You're just worried that I cannot take care of Baby Razz.
(Ok...maybe it's a parenting issue that has him upset.)
Jrazz: Absolutely not. I think you're a great dad. How would you supervise Baby Razz?
You get the idea. Getting to the heart of the matter is like peeling an onion...something he will likely be willing to do so long as he has the emotion unexpressed. However, the moment YOU take on the emotion - ie, I cannot believe that you would leave Baby Razz alone in the house while you are outside working with loud power tools!! What in the world would make you think that would be ok??! - he is satiated. (See...she never lets me have time/trusts me with the kid/listens when I talk/(fill-in-the-blank). You, on the other hand, are a whirlwind of emotions...none of which really make any sense to you.
If he is p/a, he WILL (1)set you up to (2)express what he feels.
The key is to not take the bait.
You have to be prepared to LET HIM CHOOSE.
That sounds like you aren't. It's not that. It's that he's creating a situation where he doesn't have to. Don't let that happen. Make him own it fully; it's the first step toward him having to also accept responsibility for the resulting feelings.
So, if he stands firm with wanting to work in the garage while he's got the kid, either let him manage it or make other arrangements. (And the absolute truth in that matter is that you either do trust him to supervise Baby Razz - regardless of what he's saying to you now - or you don't. If it's the latter, you need to have made other arrangements anyway.) Let him go with the female co-worker - because if he does think that's a good idea then that's telling you more than you putting a stop to it anyway. Don't give him if/then scenarios. Don't talk him out of it. Offer alternatives where appropriate (ie, Sunday garage instead of Saturday) but otherwise simply say, OK. In fact, when I am feeling my strings pulled, OK has become my first response - even when it's not ok.
If this does fit and you choose to go this direction, be prepared for things to get worse before they get better. That day he came home for lunch? Yeah. Times 10. Times 100. When you start forcing him to own his choices, it gets rough. (Forcing = you not taking them on.) When you stop expressing his feelings for him (by becoming an observer rather than participant), it gets really rough for a while. A true p/a will up the ante - pulling even crazier stuff. I DO believe there is a tipping point but it can take years to get there. And a lot of hurtful things can happen that make it sometimes hardly worth the effort. Again, logistics played a large part in my situation. It also helps that when H isn't in an "avoidance of emotion" that he's also a genuinely nice guy. I love him always - and I like him most of the time. I also strongly felt that life was bringing this lesson to me; it was something I just intuitively knew I needed to learn. So I very much felt that changing my situation would really be doing nothing more than changing logistics - that the lesson would just come in another form. The one good thing is that the more skilled I became, the less the subsequent antics bothered me. There were many times that my ego felt I was putting up with shit that I shouldn't be putting up with - but my spirit was saying, Eh...not really that big of a deal. Most of the time I really like having a pet butterfly. It thrills me when it shows up - and when it leaves, it reminds me that I am not to cling. And somehow in that, I think I've found the safety that I was once thinking I could only find in intimacy.
Hugs.