Wow. Just wow. Making this post and reading the responses has been scary, humbling, and possibly, I hope, life changing.
One of the things I did when making this post was to intentionally not tell the "whole" story. Don't get me wrong, every word in my original post is true. But I didn't tell the good parts of the relationship with WW. I didn't tell about her deep and genuine commitment to R. I didn't tell about all the work she is doing. I didn't tell about how desperately she wants a relationship with me. I didn't tell about how she has prostrated herself to me begging to know what she can do to make things right. I didn't tell how she has tried and 95% succeeded to meet my requirements for R (full NC, full transparency, IC/MC, journaling, etc.). I didn't tell how our intimacy has been transformed and we are both having deeply satisfying sex.
To be honest, my original intentions for taking this one-sided story approach weren't exactly noble. I was pissed off and wanted to rant a bit. But I now realize I inadvertently stumbled on something. By telling the most vile parts of my story I drew out painful truths about my wife (and me--more on that later) that I never would have discovered if I had taken a measured approach. I discovered that my wife has a huge blind spot regarding her personal failings. I discovered FOO issues that created this blind spot. I discovered that she has profoundly dis-ordered thinking and stunted emotional growth regarding appearance and how attraction works. Most importantly, I discovered that her ability to destroy our relationship by cheating again or some other damaging entitled behavior is much much higher than I thought. I would NEVER have discovered and realized these things if I had posted a "things are OK--some good, some bad" type of post.
If you had told me before I made this post that my wife was blame shifting, deluded, and flawed, I wouldn't have really listened or believed you. You might be thinking, "Wait a minute...are you off your meds? Didn't you write the original post?" I did!
In spite of that I didn't really believe or understand the depth of the issues involved. And here is where it gets even fucking harder. Posting in this one-sided manner and reading the responses has made me look in the mirror in a way I never anticipated. I have read suggestions about how I need to read "No More Mr. Nice Guy", about setting boundaries, and how I need to stop engaging with my wife and then think, "No, that's not me. That's not my wife. This person doesn't know me." Spoiler alert: you kinda knew me and my wife.
IQ wise, I'm smarter than the average bear. You know how much that has gotten me in this? Zilch. It has actually made things worse. My mind finds all the angles, it finds all the small flaws in others' reasoning and allows me to dismiss them and their points. My arrogance has blinded me to the wisdom of others. I have got to hold on to this new found humility and start learning and changing. I won't lie, I'm scared and daunted by the work I need to do. By so many measures (money, job, friends) my success in life has been impressive. Personal growth? Yeah, not so much. I've had some success in this area, but a lot of failures. To think that there is a new, higher mountain to climb is tough to discover.
A potentially saving grace about hearing the "whole" truth regarding my wife is that it changes her--in my opinion, at least--from being fatally flawed to profoundly flawed. If one sees all she is as opposed to just the original post I think there is hope. Could I be kidding myself? Sure, definitely could be. I've been wrong about so much in this shit storm that much of my arrogance has been stripped away. But what I'm not kidding myself about anymore is any notion that I'm a special snowflake. My situation is the same as so many on here. The work my wife and I need to do is the same.
Thank you. I would never have discovered this without this board and its partcipants. Thank you so very much.
P.S. I'm cross-posting this same reply to another one of my threads. This is kind of cheesy and maybe even against SI rules(?) but since creating these two posts I've realized they are in many ways the same post. The guidance given to me by all who responded has been invaluable and I want to say thank you to everyone. Hope that is OK.
P.P.S. Every time I think about my telling my wife she is profoundly flawed, I feel the need to say that I am too. And I am. I'm not just talking about issues in my relationship with her (boundary setting, communicating, etc.) but deep problems regarding self worth, arrogance, and self love. But talking about these issues now will end up serving to shift away from the hard, painful work she has to do. In my conversations with her I will only say that I have my own shit and I fully commit to working on it. But I won't mix the two issues. Her issues nearly destroyed our marriage and likely will finish the job off if not addressed. These come first in priority.