I'm very sorry your H has drunk this poisonous kool-aid. It has nothing to do with you. He has failed to protect himself and you. He has failed. You haven't. You just have to deal with the fall-out.
I'm pro-R. I'm sure some members think I'm the beta male poster boy.
In your case, however, there are 2 things that concern me tremendously.
The first is your H's emphasis on age. You can't change your age.
More concerning by far is his anger that you 'took' his best years. The fact that he blames you for this - when clearly he decided to give you those years - really, really bothers me, especially when coupled with the complaint about age.
The only thing that could support R, IMO, would be his coming to you on his own (without any threat of D, that is) and telling you he must have been crazy for a while, but now he's sane.
That would have to include taking full responsibility for his whole life - he screwed up, he swallowed these new 'ideas,' he realizes he gave you his years and wants to give you more, that he wants to and will be monogamous, etc., etc., etc. - and all that followed up by actions.
But if he comes to this under threat of D, I'd have a very hard time trusting him. After all, he has said he'd cheat unless you let him open the M.
I think your own mental health will require filing pretty soon - it's unhealthy to live with someone who thinks one has no value.
...counseling is all fast talking to convince him to accept a situation he abhors.
That's total bullshit.
With a good therapist, counseling is all about helping the client marshall his/her own resources to change a situation s/he abhors.
Further, he said, all men deep down know this is true but are cowed by women into falling in line.
TBH, I believe I accepted monogamyin order to get W2b into bed (this was essentially pre-Pill). Maybe I was cowed, but maybe I just did the calculations and figured I'd be happy with monogamy, as long as W2b was my partner. It didn't work out exactly as I had planned, but...
Women over 40 have no value.
This is obviously a statement from someone with the mind of a 16 year old.
Sure, at 22, the idea of sex with a 70 year old was barf-inducing for me. At 72, however, the idea of sex with a 20 year old is laughter-inducing. The idea of sex with my W, however, is extremely ... um ... let's just say ... attractive.
Do not worry. At any age, there is a range of potential sexual partners who will find you attractive.
[This message edited by sisoon at 10:34 AM, June 15th (Saturday)]