Hey DM,
See my tagline?
"If, therefore, any be unhappy, let him remember that he is unhappy by reason of himself alone.
"
I’m possibly a bit older than many posters here (reaching 50) and it’s been some years since my d-day (+25 years) but my life and career have been littered with great ups and serious downs. You know – that strange thing called “life”. If I can draw any conclusion to it all then it’s concentrated in that above quote from the Stoic philosopher Epictetus. And I truly believe that in it is the key to working oneself out of serious quandaries like the one you are dealing with.
First of all: The above posters telling you WW actions are a choice are spot on.
Now – I’m guessing your wife didn’t wake up one morning determined to have an affair but at some point in the process she DECIDED very consciously to take it that one step further than her morals and conscience (under normal circumstances) would allow. OK – she probably justified it to herself and no doubt it all rang true to her but still… She DECIDED to have an affair.
I’m a former cop and early on one of my first shifts a veteran told me to notice that no matter what the crime the perpetrator would always justify it: I had to steal that wallet to buy food, he deserved to be shot, it wasn’t rape – she wanted it… It’s the same with your wife; she justifies her affair by rewriting the past to reflect a bad marriage. Irrespective of how the marriage was. In a sense justifying an affair to a bad marriage is comparable to justifying cutting off someone’s head due to bad breath.
Second: This situation can end in two acceptable and “cope able” ways and in one unacceptable way. Reconciliation or divorce are both OK solutions. Both will eventually lead to healing, both are tough and both are attainable (with the correct attitude and effort). The ONLY unacceptable way is to remain married WITHOUT dealing with the infidelity and the underlying issues and consequences.
Unfortunately this third way is the one the WS tend to steer towards and WAY TOO MANY BS accepts and go along with.
Do this and chances are you will experience a new d-day in the next couple of years.
Keep in mind that the ONLY option of the two “desirable” ones (divorce/reconciliation) that YOU can select and implement without WW participation or approval is divorce. Think this through: If your WW does not want to reconcile then no matter what YOU do it won’t make the marriage better. Sort of like you not having had an affair does not make the marriage worse or less bad. It takes total commitment from both of you so unless and until she commits… well… divorce is your only path.
THIS IS IMPORTANT: I am NOT recommending or suggesting you divorce. In fact my advice is totally 100% based on you reconciling. Is that clear? Well – read on and you might think otherwise.
OK – So we have established that the affair is your WW decision. We have established that there are two reasonable ways out of infidelity (D/R). We have established that there is a third unacceptable option (not dealing with the issues). We have established that YOU can control D but that you need WW to go along with R.
Now – for a moment imagine you were dealing with another problem. Instead of infidelity you needed to go on a train-journey to a distant place. The trip has life altering consequences for you (life-saving treatment, life altering career… whatever). Your WW isn’t too keen so you spend some time explaining the trip, the benefits, the reasons… Yet she won’t go. So she drives you to the station and all along the drive you try to convince her… You go buy two tickets and offer her one… She goes to the platform with you and you delay boarding the train to the last call… all the time trying to convince her… She shows interest… or not… You climb onboard the train and gesture her through a window to come… She refuses. The train pulls out of the station and you see her slowly disappearing…
In a sense that’s where you are right now. YOU have to set off out of infidelity. YOU can offer your WW a path with you but at some point she has to jump on board. At some point you reach a crossroad on your journey out of infidelity where your WW joins you or your ways part.
Right now you are some way off that point. Right now you are basically still at home realizing you have to make that journey. But you better start planning and packing for it (rhetorically)
What I suggest is the following:
Always keep in mind that divorce is a possible outcome. Therefore knowing about divorce is a powerful tool. Look up and read about division of assets, debts, custody, child-support… and all other aspects of D in your state. In reality D is a relatively fair deal; best proven by the fact that normally both partners feel screwed after a divorce. But the nightmare stories you hear about losing everything in D and all that tend to be grossly exaggerated. But then – you are not planning on divorcing: you are simply getting to know your options.
Tell your wife that she is totally free to see OM. Tell her that if she truly thinks you are so bad a husband she is totally free to see OM, separate or act as single. BUT NOT AS YOUR WIFE.
Tell her (and this is an extremely powerful statement) that you have realized one thing: That discovering about the affair had been extremely painful and that the thought of the marriage possibly being over is extremely hard for you BUT you have also realized that SHARING her is immensely worse that the possibility of losing her. That you refuse to share her and that she is totally free to do whatever she wants. BUT if she wants to be in the marriage then it’s as your WIFE and that requires total fidelity.
It’s her call. You aren’t forbidding her to have affairs, she can do the local fire-station for all you care but IF she wants to be your wife she needs to commit to the marriage.
Then you tell her that until and unless she verbally commits to the marriage you will simply assume the marriage is over.
If she commits to the marriage then the two of you will have to do IMMENSE work to reconcile, including MC, IC, regaining of trust… But if she doesn’t then you will simply assume that the marriage is dead and you will start the actions of burying it.
Remove all your WW excuses and complaints.
You a bad husband? OK – Sorry she feels that way but if she doesn’t think you can change then that’s fine – the marriage is dead.
You can’t afford to divorce? Yes you can, D’s can be done cheap if there is limited conflict.
You won’t see your daughter again. Yes I will – there are rules and laws about custody. We can be great co-parents without being friends or married.
All the time reiterate: Divorce isn’t what you WANT but if she can’t commit to the marriage then it’s the only option you have.
Eventually she will either jump on that train or remain there standing on the platform. I’m betting the train because in reality only 1 in 5 marraiges dealing with infidelity do end in divorce. But at least YOU will be on your way to healing.