SWAT,
You ask what we reading your situation think about your WW and whether she “gets it”.
Well… I think she’s showing positive signs.
SWAT – I guess my view on how to deal with situations like yours are not necessarily in line with what many suggest. That’s OK – there is no black and white here and nobody should (nor could) claim to have the perfect solution.
I think one of the main reasons we are so mixed up after discovering infidelity is because we aren’t expecting it… We can’t prepare (and maybe we shouldn’t). So try substituting infidelity with another trauma, one we might be better able to relate to.
Imagine you wake up and your house is on fire… (I think I used this simile in my first post to you but bear with me…)
You can’t just lie there looking at the flames and mutter how unjust the situation is. You can’t tell yourself that since it was your wife that left the stove on and thereby caused the fire then she should call 911. You can’t save one child and then expect the wife to save the other. You can’t get half your valuables out and then sit down and pout while your wife tries to get the other half…
What you can do is evaluate whether the fire destroys the foundations of your house or whether you can rebuild.
I am one of those that think infidelity DEMANDS we act. It DEMANDS we decide. Just like the fire demands we wake up, get everyone out, get help, extinguish the flames and save what valuables we can… The tricky part is evaluating what decisions are reversible and what decisions aren’t.
I think the big issue is evaluating what we need and what we want and is attainable and then acting to reach a goal. OK – I can understand that you aren’t clear on what you want. But then you have to think: Is my indecisiveness good for me and those that depend on me? (In your case your children). Are my actions today helping in moving out of infidelity?
OK – I want to be very clear on one issue: IMHO infidelity can only end in two “positive” ways. Divorce or reconciliation. Unfortunately the third path is the one most chosen: a situation where the underlying issues aren’t dealt with and both partners learn to live with the big elephant being dragged around in the marriage.
SWAT – If you truly feel that you can’t learn to live with the fact your WW cheated and will always see her as an adulteress… Then there is no way you can ever regain or recreate a true marriage. File.
If however you think you COULD get pass these issues and IF you are willing to try… Then start reconciliation. Personally I think this is where you are at. And frankly I am not sure shunning her, ignoring her, not responding to her, an unclear and undefined separation… none of those are beneficial for reconciliation.
In an older post you say (when told OM had been in touch) that you told your wife:
My reply was this is your mess. You fix it.
SWAT – IMHO that would ONLY apply if you have already checked out of the marriage.
The mind-boggling, ground-shattering fact about reconciliation is that you are reconciling with the CAUSE of your issues.
The “mess” your wife dropped you into – as long as you are married and plan on reconciling – that is the marriages mess and thereby YOUR mess. YOU and WIFE need to handle OM being in contact IF you are still in the marriage.
And SWAT – Like I have already said there are many different suggestions on how to deal with infidelity – but I don’t think it’s your prerogative or role to dish out punishment to your wife. To start off with: What the hell is appropriate punishment for infidelity? I can’t think of any.
SWAT – Maybe the only time I was ever in a law-enforcement situation I felt I didn’t control was when I had a short-term partner that allowed a situation to escalate. He had a couple of years’ experience on me and therefore the lead-officer in dealing with some amphetamine-cooked gang members. I saw he was dealing wrongly with them and a tense situation was escalating into what could turn into a physically dangerous situation. When he had lost complete control and a couple of the guys more or less cornered him up against a wall I didn’t say “this is your mess. You fix it”. I stepped in, defused the situation and solved the problem. That SWAT is what your marriage needs.
This site was founded by a couple that reconciled after infidelity. Some of the admins and moderators are reconciled as BS or WS. I think all of them wanted their WS to suffer but I also venture that none of them really saw or had any benefit from it. I would hope that every now and then a reconciled BS looks at his/her spouse and thinks “thank God I managed to get over my initial reactions and work things out”. I would hope a reconciled WS looks at his/her spouse and thinks “Thank God we managed to put the work into being where we are and I hope I can someday forgive myself for my affair”.
And SWAT – I don’t see your wife as a super-manipulative, Machiavellian sex fiend. I see her as a super-confused and worried woman who does not have the benefit of a sounding board like SI…
Her anger and worried after your day away… Well SWAT; you are in a profession with a higher than average suicide rate, a macho society where your manhood might be seen as having been subject to shame, a society where guns are aplenty (and yes SWAT – I sucked my barrel and thought about it…). She is probably just as confused as you are, possibly even more so.
I won’t EVER excuse her affair and it will ALWAYS be her fault – her decision. But it really sounds as if OM saw a crack and pounced on it. Should she have allowed it? NO WAY.
I want to leave you with this one task; one exercise:
Sit down and THINK. Do I want to be married to this woman?
Don’t think “do I want this marriage” or “can I forgive her”. Only think “Do I want to be married with this woman”.
Whatever “marriage” comes out of R will be a completely new one IF YOU RECONCILE.
If however you come to the conclusion that you don’t want to be married to her… well… tell her so. And then start work on emotionally, physically and financially separating.