SS17, I don't have experience recovering from infidelity, so you need to take my advice for what its worth. But I do have years of painful, exhausting, but ultimately hope- and life-giving experience recovering from substance abuse and from major depression. I think they all have some things in common-- not everything, and not at all the same-- but one thing they have in common is the intense shame we feel, and how damnably difficult we find it to 1. see ourselves as we really are, and 2. break through the shame we feel to show and share who we really are, without fear, or hiding, or pretence-to ourselves first and then to those closest to us.
One rule of thumb I have found works pretty infallibly is to look hardest and most searchingly exactly where you flinch the most from looking. A second is to listen to people when they tell you where you need to look.
So when I said share, share, share it was in this specific context of looking hardest at what you most don't want to, and sharing what you see with yourself and SWAT as neutrally and truthfully as you can.
Let's apply it to what you just wrote, becuase some of it really struck me. You are so close to a really big insight into your whys, one that I think would help both you and him. Let's try to push through the last walls.
You wrote,
Most of our conversations have revolved around my affair. The PA upsets him the most because it is the most recent and well..it was physical. He keeps going back to that and he just doesn't seem or want to believe that it was just fantasy for me. He refuses to believe that he is what I really do want. He compares himself and our sex life to the affair and my journals. That and my lying about it all, have him believing that he is "lacking". Which is the farthest thing from the truth. I can tell him until I'm blue in the face, my word doesn't have a lot of weight with him now, so I'm kind of stuck.
I know stuck. Stuck usually means you are close to the heart of things, but it is too painful to look at. So we are going to look.
The PA upsets him the most because it is the most recent and well..it was physical.
This is a classic male response. It is deeply wired. And in the end, getting through it is part of his work in recovery.
But...
He keeps going back to that and he just doesn't seem or want to believe that it was just fantasy for me.
Oh, wow, did you hear it? It's right there, did you hear it? "Just." That's the bell, the clue, the signpost.
SS17, it was not, is not, and never will be "just" a fantasy. I understand, I think, what you are trying to convey--that it was never about choosing the OM as a man, as a person, over SWAT, becuase you loved/thought him better than/thought him superior than SWAT. I beleive you completely.
But the "Just a fantasy" is essentially the same as the old "it meant nothing" line anyone tries to give him or her self or him or her loved one after cheating.
By definition, it meant something. By definition is was not "just" a fantasy, becuase the allure of this fantasy for you was so powerful that it caused you to choose to betray SWAT. Look at it from SWAT's point of view--if it was "just a fantasy" and therefore it meant nothing, than he meant less than nothing, because you chose nothing over him.
It wasn't nothing. It was everything.
So stare straight at it. WHAT was this fantasy really about? WHAT need was it that was so huge and howling and insatiable that plugging it REQUIRED, NEEDED this baroque fantasy? What did fantasizing about those acts, those exchanges of power, or of humiliation, or of surrender, DO for you?
It's not enough to try to persuade SWAT that you DID NOT choose OM as a person over him. You need to be able to explain to yourself first, and him as he is ready to hear it, what you DID choose over him. Because that is the only way he can feel safe that you will not choose it again.
This is really raw stuff. I am not and would never propose that you work out all the details here. This is for IC, and later, for you and SWAT to talk though. But the fact that you kept the journal and guarded the fantasies tighter than you guarded OM himself is a huge clue that the fantasies, the need to get someone to make you feel something, is a big key.
Keep listening to yourself and to SWAT. When SWAT tells you he can't get past the sex, don't flich from it-- the "it was a fantasy, it wasn't real." You can say, "I never chose OM as a man and I never ever for an instant wanted him as a man. I know to the core of my being this is true, and I will wait and assure you and love you and help you in any way as you try to find a way to beleive me." But you ALSO have to say, "However, SWAT, you are right in a more important way--I didn't chose the OM as a man, but I chose feelings--feelings tied to sex acts--over you. And if it wasn't OM I would have found someone else. Here is what I think the feelings were... here is where they came from... here is the way I saw myself, that I was never willing to show you... here is the way I see myself now... here are the fears I have still about where that came from... here are the fears I have about what part of those feelings might still be in me even now... and that is the part that makes me not understand what you ever saw in me... or fear that you can't possibly love me."
That is what I meant by share--search, search hardest at the absolute hardest parts to look at, and share that.