I want you to really think what the worst possible outcome would be from her affair.
What is it you fear the most?
If it’s divorce or losing your wife… well… think it really through.
You see – if the fear of losing your marriage is the driving force in your life then your best bet would be to ignore the affair. After all – experience tells us infidelity-relationships seldom lasts. Your wife will have her fun and after a couple of months it will be over. Granted chances are she will move on to a new lover but in-between things might be semi-normal between you two.
You could make arrangements so that you don’t have to worry if she’s brushed her teeth… You can change sheets daily…
If this doesn’t sound good then really reevaluate the worst case scenario.
IMHO the absolute worst case scenario has got to be REMAINING in infidelity.
The issue I have with the scenario where you demand your wife does something is that it places too much power in her hands. When you tell her that she had to do a then b and tell you c “or else” places control in her hands. She can lie, she can stall, she can deny, she can react in so many ways that you can’t control… Plus she will feel coerced into whatever resolution you plan.
I suggest the following:
With no pre-warning tell your wife that you know of her affair.
You don’t have to tell her why. You don’t have to prove to her that you know. You simply state that you know, you know about the hotel and the visit to the house. No need to show her the recording.
Then tell her that you have had an epiphany. You have realized that losing her is not the worst outcome of her affair but remaining with her while she’s in infidelity is immensely worse. Furthermore then in your mind you have already lost her. The marriage you had is dead. If there is to be any reconciliation it will be a new marriage.
Then tell her she is totally free to see OM. She can go on dates with him, give him BJ’s, hold hands and skip into the sunset.
BUT NOT AS YOUR WIFE.
Then tell her that until and unless she freely on her own free will tells you she wants to reconcile and is willing to do what is required to make that possible you are simply assuming the marriage is over. All that’s left is the technical aspect of divorce.
Try to be as calm as you can while telling her this.
Don’t enter into detailed discussions about divorce. Simply say that there are procedures in place to make the process as fair as possible for both of you. Avoid arguments – this is not the time to argue. It’s the time to state facts and how things will be. If she presses then simply say “I am too emotionally attached to this marriage to discuss the details of the divorce rationally. My attorney will handle these things for me. I plan on being fair, but won’t go out of my way to accommodate your needs”.
Be very clear on this: It’s not enough that she accepts reconciliation with an “I guess so” or with a hanging hand. She has to tell you very clearly that she wants to reconcile and that she’s willing to do what’s needed to reach that goal.
Your INITIAL demands should be an immediate commitment to NC. This has to be VERY strict. She can’t call to break it off. The ONLY communication will be a short, non-personal NC letter:
“OM – Our affair is wrong and has placed my marriage at risk. I will never again contact you in any way. I demand you don’t contact me. Any contact will be shared with my husband and can have legal consequences.”
A second requirement is the name of the OM.
A third is total transparency. She has to be an open book.
If she asks for reconciliation and follows the above then you can consider looking into reconciliation.
If not or if not done clearly you simply move on.
You expose the affair. You let people know you two are divorcing because she has an affair partner (never dignify him with the title “lover”). You carry on with life but start disengaging. You split finances, have the house valued, and gather old tax returns… Basically you move on.
Chances are your reactions will confuse her. Being determined and not directly confrontational will make her wonder what she’s missing. What she’s risking.
I am guessing OM is married. After all – why the hotel and your house if he could take her to his house? You need to let his wife know the moment you get his name. Your WW might condition getting his name to not telling anyone but ignore that. Don’t tell her you will expose, just do it.