a conference 2.5 years ago
This would be June 2014?
went to a club with her friend
My opinion - that ain't no friend of the marriage.
My opinion - that ain't no friend of you.
My opinion - that friend has to go.
Does the "friend" know about the affair?
went to a club with her friend
My opinion - she shouldn't be going to "a club" without you being present any more, ever. Not with her so-called "friends" and not with her "co-workers."
My opinion - it shows disrespect for a married husband/wife to "she danced with this guy and they kissed and exchanged numbers." Does she go to "clubs" where one of the major "activities" is drinking and meeting the members of opposite sex?
Because - my opinion - going to "clubs" like that show the PERCEPTION that husband/wife is available, and apparently the other man perceived that, and apparently, that perception was accurate.
Over 2 years ago, she went to that city alone claiming to have postpartum depression and from a recent cancer scare that she was already cleared from
She talked to him for 2 months before going over there to spend 3 days with him in her hotel room. That was the only incident of sexual contact.
So this was about June 2014 - August 2014?
The 2 months "before going over there," I guess she told him how much she wanted to have sex with him, and vice versa. Was it how much she "loved" him, too?
Going "3000 miles away" on a trip by herself with no business purpose, just because she had postpartum depression and cancer scare - how does that make sense from you at that time? Why that particular city 3000 miles away? What was the rhyme/reason of that place, why would being alone like that because of that supposed reason, make sense at that time?
So she made up a "postpartum depression" so she could have sex with him? And the cancer scare wasn't really so scary after all, but it sure was a nice excuse to get some sex? Or she really did have postpartum depression and truly was scared as heck, and apparently, she found a new terrific "cure" of those things, meeting a new relationship partner and a three-day sex-fest (not great for a marriage, but a great fix for your "depression" and anxiety)?
They continued their relationship for another 7 months but then she told him it had to stop.
During the seven months, while they were supposedly still having an affair, how frequently did they text/call?
So this "STOP" was about March 2015? And during this time, I assume, there was more telling each other how much they wanted to have sex and/or "loved" each other? So she's into this guy for about 9 months? Now it ends "sexually"? How about "emotionally"? Or was it still talking about sex? And was it still "I love you's?" Is the guy married? After this, they continued as "friends" talking monthly and texting once or twice a week - what do they talk/message about? What do they have in common? All I see in common is "sex" and "I love you's." I mean, if she wanted to talk about the weather or politics or sports or women's fashions or celebrity events or movies - she has other friends, correct?
Around May 2015, we had a argument and it was about something stupid. She was careless about the car and I had gotten mad. She left the house and started texting me about divorce. I was stunned! ... Anyway, after begging and pleasing and apologizing we were back on track.
So at this point, the "AFFAIR" was over, and they were "JUST FRIENDS." Yet she was ready to DIVORCE?
A year later, this year, she found a naked picture of a girl on my phone that my brother had texted me. It was from the internet. It was nothing.
So this was about May 2016? Why did you delete the naked woman and tell your brother to stop sending you pictures of naked pictures? Why hold onto that? In my opinion, that's suspect - having a friend/brother who sends naked pictures, holding onto it - I could see why she might wonder about that.
the text messages started to come. All kinds of insults and then the D word again. We finally talked and she said that I was controlling, and nagging, etc. I agreed to go to therapy. So I did and I changed my ways.
So, I have a question. If you were always loving and respectful the entire marriage, what kind of "ways" did you have to change? This is about June 2016?
About 2 weeks before Thanksgiving, she stopped in the car for about a half hour to talk with him on the phone, AFTER a day-long "conference"?
About 1 week before Thanksgiving, she admitted to the whole "story"?
Now you have begun counseling and she claims She says she was a different person back then and that she was depressed and sick of life and didn't care and that she's gone through a lot of self improvement in the last couple years. Yes, it seems if you are depressed and sick of life and need to improve yourself, nothing works better than having an affair. So I guess she is seeing the affair as a good thing? It helped her out of her postpartum depression and her cancer scare, it helped her improve herself, and she is all good to go now, so no need for therapy, she is cured?
My opinion, you should ask her to write down a timeline of what she did and what she was thinking about while she did it. Why did she tell herself that was OK? What did her "friend" have to do with any of this?
Second, I don't know if you can tell from the way I posted, but I don't really find the whole "story" is reality - it seems like a lot of holes and things don't quite add up - and maybe part of your despair is that things don't really add up.
Did you get any evidence other than her word? There may not be any other evidence.
The part of her story that I find, probably minimized or flat-out lied - that she STOPPED the affair - I would suspect that it had cooled a bit, but if she was in contact, texting, calling on the phone - especially the calling on the phone - that is extremely probable that they were talking of sexual/romantic relationship - I just don't see them verbally talking on the phone and just talking about "how's it going, the weather is nice here, how about where you are" without going to "you make me hot, I miss you" territory. If it was truly "just friends" at that point, when you found out, then why did she have to keep it a secret any longer? Why not just have the "how is the weather there" conversation with you present, or just not care?
It is very common for the cheater to say "it ended a while ago" when it really still is going on, or just mutually on hiatus until the next time we can be together again.
I am fairly certain their texts, and even more so, their verbal conversations, were largely inappropriate content like sex and I love you and I miss you with baby talk and pet names.
The other part I suspect is a lie is the "dancing and kissing and exchanging text" in Vegas. More likely "kissing" was "sex." The other part, given the thing was going on from JUNE 2014 to NOVEMBER 2016 - 2 1/2 YEARS - there is a strong possibility they have met up more than just the one time. I am not as sure of that as I am that the conversations never went to the "friend" status of appropriateness, but still staying in contact and JUST FRIENDS MARCH 2015-NOVEMBER 2016 - OVER 1 1/2 YEARS - that doesn't add up to "just friends" or "no more sex" or "no possible future sex."
Ask for a written timeline.
Ask her to get tested for STDs.
Ditch the supposed girl"friend" who confides and maybe encourages cheating.
Blow up the affair, tell the guy's wife, ask wife to change her phone number, block him on email and phone and facebook and such.
Other than that, if you start to feel you have the truth, and she is willing to SHOW in ACTIONS, not just WORDS, that she wants to fix this, that is still some tough sledding through about 2-5 years to feel like your past it.