I’m a BW whose WH was attracted to OW primarily because of her appearance - because she was much, much more physically attractive than I am. I’m on two minds on how to answer this, because this knowledge has hurt me in ways I never could have imagined.
I’ve never been one to prioritize appearance. I’m average on a good day, and I’ve always been at peace with that. I thought I married someone who, like me, placed a greater priority on education, character, a good sense of humor, etc. Learning that my husband and I did not share the same values, and that he did not think I was attractive enough to remain faithful to? It has been an agony unlike anything I could have imagined.
On the other hand, while my self-esteem was dealt a pretty severe blow after DDay, one thing I realized was that I’d rather be me ...bland pudding, I guess
... than someone whose appearance is the means to use and be used by others, which was the case with my H’s AP.
What I am saying is, your husband will have to work through much of this himself. He will need to regain his sense of self independent of your actions, and I think that comes with doing the work he must now do, including allowing himself to go through the stages of grief.
The other part is your consistently and lovingly showing him you want to be with him. Some BSs want to hear their WS tell them they’re beautiful or similar reassurances. I don’t, because I think my H’s idea of beauty is not really in sync with my own, and also because it feels like he were to tell me I’m ‘beautiful’ now, it would just be to make me feel better, and that feels fake. But as much as anything, I don’t want to hear it because he said that to her when he’d never said it to me, and even three years out, it’s something of a trigger.
I think I’ve finally reached a place where I believe my H wants to be with me, but in my head, I still sometimes add “even though I’m not ...”. Not always, though - sometimes I let myself trust that bit of SI wisdom that says the A wasn’t about the BS or even the AP - that it was about a hole in the WS’s bucket. I guess that’s a sign of progress.
If you told your AP that he was hot - and especially if you told him he was better in any way than your BH - please be gentle and sincere with your BH without overdoing the words. Even when the BS sees that the AP was ’less than ______’ in every way, betrayal trauma takes a long, long time to recover from and heal.
We BSs can’t help but compare ourselves to the people that our spouses thought were worth the pain we feel now. Don’t try to negate what you told the AP by complimenting your husband on the same things. Instead, try to tell him what it is about him that you love. Be specific, not general: “You’re a great dad!” will make him think “....but not good enough to remain faithful to”. If you say, “I saw how patient you were when you explained that math problem to Liam; I think it really helped him to understand how to break down each question and tackle them with confidence.” You might want to add, “Thank you for letting me be here to see that.” My husband still thanks me nearly three years later, and it has helped me to see that he’s still paying attention.
You can’t ‘fix’ your BS, but you can show him you see him and value him for who he is. With consistency and a lot of time, and if he’s doing the work that he now must do, I think he’ll get to a place of trust and healing. But until then, expect a lot of bumps in the road - this stuff is so hard.
Wishing you and your BS all the best -