I just want to say to Chelsea that everything you just said over the last couple of posts was just dead on point -at least for me. Everything from distance being a factor...and especially that whole thing where you logic out "Okay, not as good looking, not as fit, not as this and not as that...must have had a magic..."
I laughed out loud, because at least in my perview that doesn't even exist. And, speaking for myself and all the women that I know what is important is their understanding of their ladies needs. So, it was so apt when you put it all together in that context.
What did the AP have that you didn't? I am going to say in most all cases the answer is nothing and probably less. Maybe just the willingness to act like your spouses was the best thing since sliced bread, the ability to create false intimacies with nick names, personal jokes,flirtations,etc.
If you knew my husband, then turned around and met the AP....you would literally look at me with a WTF on your face. That's why the only logical thing one can conclude is that it was fantasy unicorn land. I came to a point where even I looked at it with a WTF.
You have said many times that what I say and describe was an overlay of what you know of your wife's affair. RIO has said the same as well. Along with many other BH's, and other WW's. The longer I have been here the more I see of the theme, being able to articulate someones situation because it was theirs too....and bringing it back to the OP...you have a man, Frank Pittman who wrote an article, probably in the 90's that pretty much sums it up the same way.
I have to think to myself, if we know that at least a sizeable portions of affairs are like this and we know the signs and the things that lead up to it, could we not educate better against it? Instead we create books and movies and all sorts of things that glamourize, romanticize, and minimize it and make it seem like it's something altogether different then what it actually is. Education could be an inoculation against it.
We have been talking about integrity over on the WW board, and I truly believe those who have the strongest integrity know why each of their values are important to them personally. They have internal reasons that connect with it that have nothing to do with anyone else. A BW once said to me "You had an affair because it wasn't against your morals". At that time I thought no that's crazy, I knew it was wrong. But, she was right. I did not have a personal connection as to why it was important to me to uphold. I now very much have one - several actually. I have other values I uphold, and when I look at those I have a personal connection as to why. Some of them because I am educated on the subject, some of them because I had experiences that taught me why it was important to me. None of those reasons have anything to do with risk or punishment. I don't know, it just seems like there are a lot of patterns and information out there that would really help for people getting married to know.