For another perspective on the women who will jump in bed with the guy they don't care about, but withhold from the guy they do care about, that's another product of female sexual repression and conditioning.
And the logical response for a male knowing this is... I'm not saying your wrong, first off, I'm not a woman, but second, your observation appears to match with my own in dating women. But if this is true, what's your typical guys "next move" knowing this? Well, for me, it was "be the guy they don't care about". Or in the case of an A, be the guy who's opinion doesn't matter.
Women and men are both free to do what they like in the dating world, and, if you (not personally, but in general) want to make good guys wait and hop straight into bed with "bad boys" or "guys who aren't relationship material" that's your prerogative. However, it's a bit duplicitous to then wonder where all the "nice guys" are; they're hiding, either out of sight entirely or behind an "asshole mask" (my personal situation) because of this behavior in women. This behavior, while I think you captured it correctly, is not only extremely damaging to relationships but also to male/female interactions in general. It's really sad to watch this particular dance play out, you wind up with broken people on both sides of the dance floor because everyone gets hurt by it. Nice guys become assholes to get what they want, assholes then damage women by using them for sex, and then women withhold sex because they think that's why they are getting abused by men. It's a circle of pain, in many cases, a completely unnecessary one, caused at least in part by the boatload of untruth we stick in (or at least did, when I was a child) male and female children's heads. It's just very sad all the way around.
Sorry, it didn't make any sense to me if his wife was so small ;-) It still doesn't ;-)
I'll agree with the first part, it doesn't make sense. It's an irrational fear/worry, I'll concede that without argument. However, what you said after this, I don't say it only to identify with other BH's, it's "real" for me too and I do think/worry/get sick thinking about it. Honestly, I think even a guy in the 99% for penis size would probably be worried about it, perhaps not if the other guy was bigger, but if the other guy was "more comfortable" for her. No matter how many times I'm told "size doesn't matter" it's very difficult to see that as the "whole truth" around sexual pleasure. Does it matter "a lot"? I don't think it does. But does it matter to some people, do some women find bigger (or smaller) to be a lot more pleasurable? I find it difficult to believe that the answer is "no"; I've certainly found some vaginas to be a better/more pleasurable fit than others, so it hard to believe that same dynamic doesn't apply for women. Now, perhaps here is where the parallel can be drawn, a very tight woman who's a "dead fish" in bed isn't going to be as good a sexual experience for me as a much looser woman who's screaming at me to f her harder, pull her hair and put my finger in her a**. The 2nd is going to be better for me because that's shows engagement, excitement and "letting go" in bed with me, and that's something I really enjoy and look for in a sexual partner. And maybe that's what people mean when they say "size doesn't matter", it's the other things about sex that matter MORE than size. The problem there is though, if we take woman number 2 who's totally into sex and is pushing all my buttons and limits in the bedroom and give her a "better fit" vagina for me, that would be better. And because of that thought in my head, size starts to matter a lot more to me when you put it in context of an affair. You did everything with him, it was forbidden, stolen moments, taboo, in public, exciting, AND he was hung like a horse?? Well, that's one of those "how can I compete with that" kind of thoughts for me, I can never bring all those elements together because some of them (the "sleeping with someone new") simply aren't something I can recreate.
I'd never argue it's an entirely rational fear. But it's a fear, it's there, and I think that a whole lot of other men would echo that they've worried about this too in the past, both for relationships and much more so for me personally, coming out of an A.
[This message edited by Rideitout at 6:13 AM, October 16th (Wednesday)]