BSHusbandWI
You have gotten a lot of advice – some good and some maybe not so good…
There are relatively few constants in infidelity, but there are patterns and behaviors that we here on SI have seen again and again. Despite each case being unique then people tend to react the same way to comparable situations. Like right now your wife is reacting just the way probably 19/20 WW react: She’s trying to minimize the affair, hiding facts, protecting herself and the OM.
Based on what you share OM is married: Burner phone and hotel hookups (if single then he would use his home). Keeping the key is odd: You get a key at check-in and keeping it after use is strange unless the room is kept for several days. This in turn costs, indicating a wealthy OM.
You can bet your last dollar that she has told him you know and in 9/10 cases the married OM reacts the same way: Let’s cool things down until the coast is clear. He’s hiding evidence, being attentive to his wife and maybe even concocting some story about a crazy guy accusing him of “stuff”. But for NOW, the affair is over.
Also based on what you share he sounds quite confident or experienced. It’s not the back-seat of a car or sneaking a quickie in the office-supplies room. It’s “pro”-like, with hotels, accessories, the burner phone…
Your WW reactions to cooling it down are also in line with 9/10 WW: She has every intention of the affair being over. Just like the last time you had a big hangover you were determined not to drink again… But just like you probably had a beer a week later then chances are at least 5/10 that once she thinks it’s safe she will reach out to him.
The odds are 8/10 that if HE reaches out after a couple of months she will restart the affair. The odds are 8/10 that he WILL reach out to her again. The moment he thinks he’s safe he will reach out again.
If you have any way of monitoring their communications, then once she told him you know he would probably have responded with an open ending. It’s not “we need to quit, and I will never contact you again” but rather something along “It’s best we don’t see each other for now”. Not final, but more like a time-out.
Those are terrible odds altogether… Not odds I would want to base my future on.
Fortunately, there are things you can do that increase your odds. They are also more-or-less in line irrespective of if you want to reconcile or divorce.
Keep in mind that either option is fine, considering where you are now. Divorce might sound frightening but it’s the only option YOU have some control over. Reconciliation is great too but requires BOTH are totally on-board. TOTALLY. Right now, your wife isn’t, or at least it’s not clear she’s there for the right reasons.
There are also some things we know from collective experience that also apply to reconciliation.
The KEY issues are two:
(a) The affair needs to be over.
(b) You need the truth.
The first couple of months in R are usually spent either getting those two requirements fulfilled OR getting you to the point you feel safe on both issues.
You are missing a KEY ISSUE here. One that more-or-less ensures you don’t have (a) the affair needs to be over. Namely the NAME of the OM.
You don’t know what you are dealing with. Without knowing who he is you are missing the key tool to ending the affair and a major issue for YOUR assurance.
Look – even if your WW is that one in ten WS that really ends an affair after d-day and even if she NEVER again talks to or meets OM then for the rest of your life/marriage you will be wondering. Who is he? Who is the OM? Is it George across the street? Is it Jeff – the man your WW said hi to at the Mall? Is it the guy looking at her across the restaurant? YOU will never feel safe. YOU will be incapable of reconciliation irrespective of her commitment.
You don’t need to talk to him or even meet him. But you do need to know who he is, how they met, how they communicated… Then – without telling your wife – you need to let his wife know. It’s not revenge (although it has that positive side-benefit…) but rather something that increases your odds immensely.
Our collective experience shows that once the OMW knows the OM commits to his marriage.
Experience tells us that being shunned or getting a firmer “it’s over” from the OM tends to get the WW out of the fog quicker.
The odds of the affair restarting drop considerably. You know better what you are dealing with. Your position to decide whether to reconcile or divorce becomes better.
Most of us on SI agree (mostly through personal experience AND shared) that the key moment for us betrayed spouses is when we realize we can’t control the WS, but we can control US and what we accept and want.
We also realize that what we want is dependent on what others offer. You can want to reconcile as much as you can, but if she doesn’t want it and if you two don’t commit to it (like with her telling you all) then it can’t be attained.
If you can only control yourself and if R is dependent on her actions… well… maybe your best bet is to start the divorce process. But keep in mind it’s a PROCESS. It takes time and consists of many steps and milestones before the Big D is attained. For a good part of that journey the path of Reconciliation runs parallel. It’s easy to switch paths if things change.
I challenge you to think this through: Your marriage as it was is over. Dead. Whatever happens now is a new marriage or a new life apart. Both are OK. The only really BAD option IMHO is to remain in infidelity.
What would be immensely worse than divorce or spending time trying to fix things is for her to remain in infidelity mentality (protecting OM, secrets, limited commitment…) or for you to discover yet another Hilton key. THAT would be the worst.
If you agree with that then consider telling her something along these lines:
“Wife. I envisioned us being married forever. This affair was an immense shock, but I think our past deserves that we try to reconcile. However, I have made an immense, liberating realization: As much as I fear losing this marriage then I fear even more SHARING you.
I don’t share my wife, nor do I intend to. I don’t intent to keep you in this marriage against your will. If you don’t think a monogamous marriage built on honesty and mutual respect is attainable for us or if you think our marriage demands too much sacrifice, then that’s OK.
You are totally free to spend time with OM, meet OM, go to his seedy hotel-room, talk about him with your friends… whatever… BUT NOT AS MY WIFE.
Until and unless you tell me in a very clear and unequivocal way that you want me as your husband I’m simply assuming you have still chosen your affair over our marriage. I release you from your obligations and expectations as my wife, just like I resign my role as your husband.
That’s OK. I’m fine with that. It’s not what I want, but definitely better than remaining in infidelity.
I will initiate and work towards the emotional, logistical and legal process of terminating our marriage. The legal system will ensure we both get a fair deal. I will place the legal aspects in the hands of my attorney because I am too emotionally attached to this marriage.
If you want this marriage and tell me so in a clear unequivocal manner, then there are some requirements I need. I need total commitment, accountability and transparency and I need the name of the OM. Without this then I know we can’t reconcile and I’m OK with that. It beats sharing you.”
And then you go and do something else. Watch a rerun of Friends, mow the lawn… whatever.
If she wants to talk the ONLY things you might discuss is how to tell the kids, how to live together the next weeks, mediate or separate attorneys… Other than that, it’s the 180.
If she says she had the affair because you were emotionally distant: “I’m sorry you feel that way. We would need to address this if we were working on reconciliation, but since you have decided to choose your infidelity over our marriage there isn’t any need to go there”.
This is your standard go-to answer to ANY marital issue.
It’s only if she tells you she wants the marriage AND shares the required info that things change.
If you work at detaching, accepting that without 100% commitment the affair is still ongoing and do the 180 you do two things:
You create pressure on HER to commit to you or the affair. Both are OK. If she commits to the affair you get your inevitable truth. If she commits to you it’s then done from a more truthful base.
You create the environment where YOU become OK and even accept divorce IF she doesn’t change her stance.
[This message edited by Bigger at 8:38 AM, June 23rd (Tuesday)]