Friend
When posters comes along and posts comments like this being the toughest situation ever witnessed here on SI, you have no vision or are totally blind to what’s happening, you are weak and so on it’s sometimes beneficial to look up their older posts on other threads. You often see a pattern of the same this-is-the-worst-case-ever-seen, you-are-weak, kick-her-to-the-curb advice offered as a cure-all to all situations.
Fareast and Buffer have both given the excellent advice that you can pace yourself and that you need to focus on the main character in this drama: Yourself. There are few things that hold completely true in marital problems but this one is: If you take time away from your problems they will still be there when you get back. If you use the time away wisely YOU are in better shape to deal with the problems.
I don’t know if this situation is recoverable or not. Frankly I’m not too hopeful it can be done CORRECTLY. I put great value in marriage, I think it’s the most important relationship we enter purely of free choice and stay of free choice in our lives. To me as I see it a marriage needs to be built on truth and trust. IF she’s holding back on OM name – IF – then it shows she doesn’t trust you and there is no truth. IF you don’t believe she knows OM name then that too shows you don’t trust her and there is no truth.
Reconciliation is tough. Going at it with THAT albatross around your neck is like setting off on a cross-country road-trip with a bad car-battery and leaky tires.
The KEY ISSUES right now to me is this:
Is she telling the truth about OM name?
Do you believe her that she doesn’t know OM name?
Is she willing to share all info that might give you OM name? Not just allow you to search her info, but actively contribute to the search.
We have offered some suggestions on how you could establish if WW knows his name or not. I’m sticking to the poly suggestion.
Present this as her tool to help YOU move on from her not knowing the name.
If she refuses then suggest hypnosis and/or ask her for suggestions on how she can help you move on from this issue.
Her reaction will tell you a lot. A lot. In fact, if she right away offers to take the poly then to me that would be enough.
The issues in her story that make me take a step back and think?
Well… I can understand getting a burner phone once an affair has started, but are we to believe the OM already had a burner when he met WW? That his wife then got a burner to send WW a message? What level of experience does he have to a) already have a burner dedicated to this affair b) keep his name hidden all the time? If he’s a played does he have one phone per affair partner? Does the man walk around with 4 phones in his pants marked Wife, Jane, Cindy and Sue? It’s too CSI, too clean and sanitized for me. Too convenient. Too unbelievable.
The fear of OMW reaching out to your wife? That is classic, happens-all-the-time fear here on SI. In my many years I have heard that fear mentioned several times each month. I recall less than 100 instances where the other spouse has harassed the AP and then usually with a call or text or two. There are maybe 2-3 over the last 10 years where it’s gotten any further than that. It’s an empty threat, especially considering the benefits of knowing OM name and ensuring his wife knows (and the “message” from OMW being a lie).
Finally. What I fear the most for you is this:
We had a poster here some years ago. He still posts occasionally. His wife insisted she “only” had an EA. Yet he had posts describing their sex, OM and WW having spent nights together in a hotel room and so on and so on. This poster wanted to reconcile, and his wife wanted to stay married. Eventually she agreed to a poly and if I remember correctly completely failed twice. Not just failed but more like broke the needle failed. Yet she insisted it was only an EA. They are still together as husband and wife, but IMHO his posts reflect a growing despair. To me it’s not the actual events that took place in an affair that will kill his marriage, but rather the lack of knowing. This is what I fear for you.