Brisee,
I have thought about the trust issue (rereading the below, I suppose maybe too much) too and it is scary. Part of me wanting to R was that I feel like I can better deal with the devil I know than the one that I don't (or however that saying goes). Either I will never trust again, so why not stick with WW, or I will have a hard time trusting, so why not let her try to build that with me before moving on. I mean, we had a good relationship for so long that maybe she would come around? However, as I think about her ability to look me straight in the face and lie to me over the past couple of months, I realized that she has become too comfortable deceiving me. Perhaps many people are capable of the same skill (I've come to realize that my wife is not unique/special in most ways). Just look at this site - it is getting close to the 60k member mark, adding 10k new members in less than two years, and only a small subset of couples dealing with infidelity in english speaking countries likely find their way here. But, I also think that the lying and deceit are part of the A / addiction pattern and it's much easier to trust someone so long as you are not in this situation.
I told WW that I have come to peace with the fact that she will do whatever it is she wants and then tell me whatever it is she wants about what she's doing, with the two unlikely to coincide. I have told her what I need to start rebuilding trust, but she's not really interested in taking those steps and just kind of responds that I should start believing her again. That doesn't feel like remorse to me and so R is not in the cards for now. I expect that our lack of trust will make for an unhealthy co-parenting relationship, but it's what WW's served up.
So, looking at trusting in a new relationship, I have basically decided that I shouldn't expect to trust for a long time. By setting low expectations upfront, I hope to not get hurt too badly. Plus, not everyone is for everyone and so I expect to face a lot of rejection when dating outside of just the trust issues. I mean, I plan to be open and honest in my relationships, but I understand that it takes time to build trust with a stranger. I will see how things evolve with each potential partner and have a high alert for signs. I've set up two dates so far, one with someone I've known off and on since high school and a parent of one of the girls from my DD's kindergarten class (connected with both of them on an OLD app). I realize that I'm likely doing that because there is some shared element that makes me feel comfortable that there is likely some upfront trust. But I'm also setting up dates with complete strangers and, again, have a lower expectation for trust.
The final point worth mentioning with respect to trust, in my mind, is the impact that smartphones are having on relationships. Both you and I, and most people on this site, started our now broken relationships prior to the advent of smartphones. If you have listened to or read any Esther Perel (the TED talk is at least worth a listen), she says that smartphones have made it 1. easier to cheat than ever before and 2. easier than ever to get caught. Let's deal with them in reverse order:
First, my WW and I were already married at the time that we got our first iPhones. Given that we had built a relationship of trust for a number of years prior to that, it was never contemplated that we wouldn't have access to each others phones. Heck, we probably didn't even have passwords until at least the last couple of years. And even then, my WW didn't bother to change her password when she started to communicate with OM via Whatsapp. I'm not sure how access to phones evolves in new relationships that form in the post-smartphone era. Is there some point in a relationship, after having the exclusivity talk, where you sit down and agree to give each other phone access, or does it evolve naturally (i.e. check out the picture from the other day, my password is x), or is it just expected that phones are a private domain and no access is granted? There are other ways of getting caught, but this seems to be the prime avenue, in my mind. So, if I never have access to my partner's phone, I suppose I will be subject to higher risk of being cheated on. So again, I will go into new relationships more guarded and a lower expectation for trust.
Second, it seems like OLD apps have created a proliferation of opportunities and, for better or worse, monogamy is probably hard to come by. I was reading someone's OLD profile the other day that summarized the dilemma well. Basically she said: everyone is looking for THAT person, but no one is willing to be THAT person. Even though most profiles say something along the lines of "looking for something serious," it seems too tempting with all of these options for people to keep reaching for the next best thing rather than to settle down (see my earlier comments on settling down and pair that with the fact that there are a lot of people in their late 30s in NYC that still haven't chosen a life partner). Perhaps there are ponds to fish in where that is not the case, as eHarmony might pitch to clients, but I have come to realize that I can't expect monogamy when I start to date. Maybe that's not such a bad thing, at least at first. However, even after the conversation of exclusivity, it just seems too tempting to check Tinder "one more time" or to continue to flirt with the people still in the queue, whether or not there are issues in the relationship.
I hope that I'll have time to figure it out, but for now its just about setting low expectations.
[This message edited by NotYetConvinced at 3:22 PM, July 26th (Wednesday)]