Arbuom
This might be a slightly harsh post…
I feel you need focus.
I for one am not sure what you want. What your goal is.
If it’s divorce… Then go for it.
Skip the drama. Tell your wife that you are filing – whether you do so before you consult with an attorney or not or before you file or not – that isn’t really the big issue. Personally, I would suggest learning your rights and having a clear picture of the effects before filing, but in any case, then IF you think divorce is the path you WANT then juts start that journey.
You don’t have to justify divorce to anyone. It’s not a game. It’s not as if your friends will keep score and then at the end of the day you get 6 points and wife gets 3 and therefore you win. If you want to divorce, then divorce. It’s TOTALLY your call. It’s not a popularity contest. You don’t do it to “win”. You don’t do it to punish your wife.
IF you want to divorce you do so because YOU want to divorce. Maybe because you don’t have another realistic option, but maybe because you want to divorce.
All this talk about having her served unexpectedly, shaming her, trying to cause her pain… That’s not for me. There is nothing kind or nice about divorce and to me it would be worth a LOT to be able to go through that process and still can hold your head high because you never hit below the belt.
At the same time, I think even an amicable divorce is a messy one. I think a big mistake people divorcing make is thinking they will be friends and still spend time together. I can more-or-less guarantee that for a 6-12-month period post-divorce you two will hate each other’s guts.
If you want to reconcile…
Well… that’s harder. Harder but still possible…
IF she changes her attitude.
That’s the key issue. To reconcile you need a couple of things just to even start that path. You – as in Arbuom – needs to want to reconcile and she – as in Mrs. Arbuom – needs to want to reconcile. Those are the two most important factors. Then you both need to realize what basics are needed to take the first teeny-weeny step. Generally, that’s her understanding that the truth is necessary, and then it’s YOUR willingness to let her tell the truth and not react rashly to whatever she tells you.
But right now, it’s a moot point…
She has told you she doesn’t love you, won’t love you, you are controlling, that she’s done nothing wrong…
That leaves you with one path open.
Remember how I told you the paths to R or D run parallel to begin with?
You can choose whether you walk on the R-lane or the D-lane for the first steps. That first step is to let your wife know that YOU are leaving infidelity and that since she wants to remain behind then YOU are moving on.
BTW – Maybe I’m jaded from too many years on SI, but I don’t see your wife as the penultimate evil and calculated hex. A lot of her actions are in line with a deep EA and are no worse or better than many others. You are dealing with a tough situation and I don’t see a need to paint it any darker than it really is.