It seems to me she is a taker and you are a giver.
It seems you are worried, maybe even afraid, to lose her, but she is not as much to lose you.
If I cheated at work I would understand implicitly that I would have to quit. My wife cheated through a group she was involved in, she understood that must end immediately. It took a few minutes and it happened within a fee hours after me confronting.
I think anyone who cheats understands this if they want to repair the marriage, it's just that sometimes they don't love the betrayed spouse or is selfish, caring more about themselves. This is, to me, a form of cake-eating, "I get to cheat at work AND I get to stay working with the affair partner."
I tell you this to compare what remorse looks like. But I think most of us inside understand how much our spouse cares about us when we clearly communicate how we feel.
It is OK to be afraid of losing her and would rather stay together. I think some betrayed spouses want that. The problem is to think you can change her or make you care more. She is showing you in actions, though she may say some very pretty words.
I also must wonder about what you think is going on here? Saying stuff like "it's hard on her, too."? What is so hard? You are asking her to leave the job. You know what my dad whispered to me on his death bed? He said he regretted only one thing. He whispered in my ear and said, "Son, I just wish I could have spent more time at work and less time with my wife and kids." Do you believe that? Because it was a joke, no one ever says that. Your wife will have other jobs, they will discard her when they have no more value for her, but she will not find another guy like you.
You have to love yourself a little more. It is OK to sacrifice greatly for someone you love, but that is a really hollow feeling when you realize the one you sacrifice for doesn't love you, respect you, or appreciate you, and won't sacrifice AT ALL for you.
I wonder also what you think about her feelings for you and her feelings for other men and Other Man in particular. She was falling for him, she liked him enough to risk her marriage, have sex with her, and still stay in close contact - she sees him there 8 hours a day, 5 days a week. What do you think she feels about him. Do you think she dislikes him now? He is telling her how great she is and how he wants her - if a woman told you that at work, while you might refrain, what would you think of her?
I don't feel like you have a grasp of what is going on with your wife and you are setting yourself up for another fall.
If you were to just drop it - just stop bringing it up - what do you think would happen? Do you think she would go through with telling HR? Do you think she would quit? Do you think she would bring it up again?
After I confronted, I told her I could not continue if she was involved in that group where she had the affair with other man. She asked would emailing be OK to quit? I said yes, and she emailed right in front of me and that was the end of that. No argument, no waiting, no foot-dragging. In my opinion, if my wife had foot-dragged it for weeks, then finally did it after I cajoled her and nagged her, I would have quite a bit of resentment and anger. My wife knew, though, that I wouldn't wait that long.
My advice to you is to do what you want, but understand your situation and what your wife is doing. It is OK to wait, it is OK to just let it go, but don't look at that as "remorse.". Be OK with what you want and what is acceptable. I know for a fact that some guys I respect would never stay married if their wife cheated, and I know this because they actually divorced immediately. I stayed and reconciled with my wife, but I knew what was acceptable and what was not to me and I was OK with it.
[This message edited by wk55hn at 9:49 AM, November 10th (Thursday)]