Gmc, that was a really helpful post.
LifeDestroyer, I hear echos in your posts of learned helplessness. It's an idea that if you fail over and over, you will give up trying and have an implacable belief that there is nothing you can do that will create a different outcome. You see it in kids who are learning disabled or dyslexic; when they are finally diagnosed and get the help they need, even if the teacher is skilled and empathic, the child has ceased trying because they believe in their gut that they will never be able to learn. They won't open a book, look the teacher in the eye, they'll avoid going to class, etc. It's what keeps enormous elephants "chained" up with a small rope at the ankle - they initially had strong chains and fought against the chains, but after fighting and fighting and not being able to escape, they stop trying and are kept chained up essentially by their beliefs.
The initial learned helplessness studies were really unpleasant. An average rat is a fantastic swimmer. A rat dropped in a bucket of water will swim and swim for hours before drowning. 60 hours on average. The researchers created learned helplessness in some rats by squeezing them until they stopped struggling, over and over. They learned not to bother with struggling because they couldn't make the squeezing stop. Those rats swam for an average of 30 minutes before drowning, even though they were physically as capable as the others. They believed there was nothing they could do to survive and gave up.
There are other studies with dogs and shocks. They're very depressing. Learned helplessness is critical to keeping systems of slavery in place and might explain why many emancipated slaves in the south "sold" their labor to the very plantations they were liberated from, re-entering the same life despite their apparent freedom. The point is, it's an extremely common and cross-cultural/cross-species thing, and probably the basis of depression in many people.
I hear some of that in your posts and in your actions - everything is awful and nothing can be done. When I make practical suggestions sometimes, you write back how it won't work instead of trying to figure out how it can.
I'm not blaming you for this or judging you or disliking you or any of that. When I see learned helplessness in kids or in adults, it makes me furious for them! What I wonder is, where did that come from? I wonder if when you were very little there was nothing you could do to manage the chaos in your house or family, if you tried to make things better but over and over you couldn't, so you learned that in relationships or in families there is no point in trying because nothing will change.
I'd also like to say, if any of this resonates with you, those people who made you feel like that are horrible! Your child is 5, can you imagine making her feel like that!? That when she says she is scared, there's nothing that can be done about it but stay scared? When she says is cold, too bad, she just has to stay cold? And if she goes to get a blanket it's taken away from her for some random undefined reason? If she feels ill, there's no point in going to the doctor or taking medicine, she just has to suffer with it? When she makes some effort to do something, she is told that she can't change or fix anything? That is a TERRIBLE thing to teach a child. It is among the WORST things you can do to a child. To deprive them of agency and hope.
I wonder if this is why you didn't speak up more when there were things in your relationship with your husband earlier that you didn't like. And I wonder if it's why the affair held such appeal, because you feel like finally you had agency and effect on another person and there was something you could do to lift your underlying depression.
Maybe I'm totally off base but I think it's a useful idea for you to think about. There are exercises and protocols for learned helplessness, and even acknowledging that's what's happening could be helpful. And it would be so helpful for your husband to have some sense of why the affair happened. If he's like most husbands, he's over there thinking that you had an affair because he's not a good enough man, and he needs a compelling narrative that jives with what he knows about you to combat that narrative.