Zugzwang, I'm a BW; It does help when reading and responding to know a bit about the other poster so I updated my sig line. I'm glad you asked because I've been meaning to do that for quite awhile now.
Why would taking ownership in causing a rift in someone else's life mean you can't work on you? Is it really changing and being a person of integrity and honor if you can't take ownership of causing harm to other people? Really? Is that where a WS should stop growing? Just admitting they harmed their BS?
I didn't say he shouldn't take ownership of the harm he's caused. Quite the opposite, I think he needs to focus on the real harm, not the fallout from the harm. The conversation was specifically about whether fDad is to blame for the D between his former AP and her BH.
The point I was trying to make was a fine one but I think it's an important one. I shared my thoughts because they might help someone who is spinning themselves in circles to figure out why they feel the way they do about something but can't quite grasp it in order to deal with it because oftentimes, our focus is not on the thing that will make it clear to us.
WS can spend the rest of his days beating himself up for destroying AP's marriage but that doesn't accomplish anything because that marriage will still be over. Just as a R between AP and BH wouldn't have changed anything as far as fDad is concerned because R doesn't erase the pain, the agony, the other types of fallout in terms of job losses, financial losses, community standing, that WERE caused by him and for which he is responsible and has the obligation to repair to the best of his ability. His actions caused those things. His actions did not cause the AP & BH to get divorced.
So, like the little boy who just beat himself up over what he already did instead of fixing himself so he doesn't continue to make the same bad choices, I think was what OP was trying to say. I don't think he was trying to minimize, I think he was trying to hone in on the root causes and focus on what he needs to do to become the man he wants to be.
Analogies can be tricky but let's look at the drunk driving one a little deeper and maybe you'll see what I'm driving at (no pun intended). Let's say you and I go out and get drunk. On the way home, I drive us into a ditch and you get badly injured. Oh, my, I injured my friend, I injured my friend, I'm a terrible person, I'll have to beat myself up for the rest of my life, I hurt my friend, I'm a bad person.
Now, let's change the scenario up a little bit. You and I go out and get drunk and then I drive you home. I drop you off and I go home and go to sleep. Ah, good, I'm a good person, I didn't hurt my friend, I took good care of my friend, I'm a good person.
Right? Not in the least because getting you home safely doesn't change the fact that I drove while I was drunk which was wrong, illegal and just plain dreadful. And I should feel horrible about it. I drove drunk and I risked my friend's life and the lives of many other innocent people. THAT is what I need to work on. Why did I drive when I was drunk? And how do I fix that part of me that allowed me to think it was an OK thing to do?
Now, maybe I'm wrong about all of this and I'm certainly open to pursuing the conversation further. I don't mean to sound like a school marm, I really and truly am just trying to help people narrow the focus. IF they want to. Maybe it doesn't help other people to get that focus but it does help me so I shared.
***************************
I tend to go on and on and on and give people eyestrain but I do have one more little snippet that might be useful if you want to read further. I'm 70, I met my XWH when I'd just turned 18 in 1967; we married in 1972. He went into alcohol rehab in 1982 after ending a short affair with a barfly. We moved away and to be honest, I never really thought about her ever again. She was immaterial to my life. But to be honest, I don't know if XWH ever thought about her anymore or what he thought if he did. He got heavily involved in AA and as luck had it, so was his new boss so he got pretty entrenched in living by the Big Book and also in his wonderful new job. I was living AlAnon and began my stint as soccer Mom/suburban housewife (again, my career on hold while we all healed from all the turmoil). So life was good for us. Fast forward to 2017, he's still dry, but no longer in AA. He goes to his 50th class reunion and gets swept off his feet by his old girlfriend who's there with her 3rd H. He started a long distance affair with her, I found out, we divorced and he's now married to her and living the good life in TX.
Which one of those women is responsible for my divorce? I hate them both, of course, but it was MY decision to divorce and they didn't even enter my mind as being factors. The first one was young and foolish and a drinker and was looking for a big shot (he did well in his career) so I don't actually hate her. The one he's married to now? She's a whore, always has been. She thought he had money and she pursued him relentlessly. Do I blame her that I threw him out and filed for Divorce? I blame her for being a money-hungry, lying whore but I don't blame her for my divorce. I blame her for the pain that she's caused so many people, including her own children and stepkids and her poor ex-husband who didn't know about the A until I called him after their divorce was final. The things I blame her for are far worse that my decision to Divorce.