Cookies are required for login or registration. Please read and agree to our cookie policy to continue.

Newest Member: Omega2752

General :
Really a groundbreaking study...

default

 Unconventional (original poster member #87720) posted at 10:39 PM on Sunday, November 15th, 2026

Nope. This website—though long-established and large—isn’t actual data at all! You’d have to actually look at outcomes for those who choose not to establish and maintain NC to know the success rate of that approach. Most people who refuse NC and still pursue R know better than to stay involved at a website like this because such posters will only get raked across the coals here by a whole bunch of feisty—I write this with respect, BTW—folks. Frankly, it’s not even just the BSs who criticize a lack of imposed NC. WSs not uncommonly pay a huge price to accept NC. Getting a WS who accepted NC at such immense costs to tolerate any other WS not having to forsake the AP is arguably even a harder needle to thread than obtaining the same bitter acceptance from a BS! I just have the resiliency of being someone who has been unpopular my whole life and so am relatively resistant to attempted smackdowns.

[This message edited by Unconventional at 10:42 PM, Sunday, November 15th]

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 176   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909573
default

Unhinged ( member #47977) posted at 11:04 PM on Sunday, November 15th, 2026

laugh

Married 2005
D-Day April, 2015
Divorced May, 2022

"The Universe is not short on wake-up calls. We're just quick to hit the snooze button." -Brene Brown

posts: 7632   ·   registered: May. 21st, 2015   ·   location: Colorado
id 8909575
default

BackfromtheStorm ( member #86900) posted at 11:13 PM on Sunday, November 15th, 2026

I missed the subtext because I just read the corpus of topic.

Did you ever wonder if the roles were reversed how you would really feel?

It’s an exercise in empathy, but is not as difficult to imagine how you may feel if your wife would have another man stuck in her thought while sitting next to you.

Although at this stage you might be more inclined to worry if other woman has replace you with another man in her thoughts and how that makes you feel.

You can try and see if you can conclude it feels fine.

You are welcome to send me a PM if you think I can help you. I respond when I can.

posts: 1247   ·   registered: Jan. 7th, 2026   ·   location: Poland
id 8909576
default

 Unconventional (original poster member #87720) posted at 11:57 PM on Sunday, November 15th, 2026

Accidental duplicate post with the following post. Sorry!

[This message edited by Unconventional at 12:06 AM, Monday, November 16th]

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 176   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909579
default

 Unconventional (original poster member #87720) posted at 12:01 AM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

This risks coming dangerously close to seeking support, but: yes, I have.

The key is: if my W had a male friend like I want to have my OW be a friend, I would encourage my W to keep the friendship.

I am presently fully NC with my OW to accommodate R of the M.

When our M and we have healed, and I am ready to "behave," I hope to reconnect with my OW in a very structured and properly-ordered friendship. I used to be someone who thought I wasn't one of "those cads" who would ever commit infidelity. I fell into my waywardness by at least 1000 small steps--many of them independently defensible. (I do not claim that my infidelity was "right" in spite of the fact I would defend many of my individual steps on the path I treaded that led me to that shameful end.)

As it happened, toward the very end of my relationship with my OW, she was asked out by another man and she told me so. I was giddy-happy for her over that news! (That's because the nature of my relationship with my OW was of a friendship that became too central--never a romance and never sexual in the slightest.)

Anyhow, it's relevant that I have scrutinized how I screwed-up and have meticulously designed safeguards to protect both my M and my friendship with the OW if ever I am privileged to have that back. Point being: if I were ever to cross the line again with my OW, I know I would have to end the friendship permanently. And that friendship--while "just" a platonic friendship and currently on-the-rocks--has been one of the most consequential relationships of my lifetime. Not as much as my spousal relationship--but perhaps #2. So... while it would cost me dearly to end the friendship permanently, I would do so. But, if I can keep the friendship rightly ordered--and I've invested hundreds and maybe thousands of hours in ensuring that I can--I want that friendship back. With my very life, I will guard the borders of my M to keep it safe--and thereby protect the friendship for life.

[This message edited by Unconventional at 12:07 AM, Monday, November 16th]

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 176   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909580
default

torso1500 ( member #83345) posted at 12:24 AM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

Also, I will point out that my W and I are Catholic. Catholic marriage ceremonies have to follow a strict text. Catholics do not promise each other in marriage ceremonies that we will "forsake all others" for the sake of our spouse.

Yikes...you think the Catholic conception marriage will give you the wordplay leeway you're trying here?? Is FIDELITY not part of the vows?

You are deep in Wayward thinking.

posts: 110   ·   registered: May. 16th, 2023
id 8909581
default

InkHulk ( member #80400) posted at 2:19 AM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

This site is far far far better data than this survey you cite as a research study. Know why? Cause there are actually healed people here, lots of them. And we compare notes on how we got there. And we also see on the regular the absolute agony that contact with an AP caused the betrayed. Many of us have experienced it ourselves. So your wordsmithing bullshit to justify the inexcusable will go absolutely nowhere.

#fiesty

But, if I can keep the friendship rightly ordered--and I've invested hundreds and maybe thousands of hours in ensuring that I can--I want that friendship back

You are obsessed. Over someone you mostly know online. Again, all the words and all the theology in the world doesn’t cover over the rot of what you are doing.

People are more important than the relationships they are in.

posts: 2988   ·   registered: Jun. 28th, 2022
id 8909583
default

BackfromtheStorm ( member #86900) posted at 7:40 AM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

The key is: if my W had a male friend like I want to have my OW be a friend, I would encourage my W to keep the friendship.

I am presently fully NC with my OW to accommodate R of the M.

That’s very close to gaslighting though.

Nobody ever needed to reconcile for a friend of the opposite sex.

You don’t have your friend stuck in your mind as an obsession, because if that ever happens then it’s clear it is not just friend.

You need to find self honesty, your wife is not crazy throwing a tantrum over an innocent friendship.

Or if she is, then she needs help. Friends also don’t come first when your partner is involved.

If this "friend" keeps taking priority, the. Again, this connection is more important than the marriage.

That’s not just friendship.

You are welcome to send me a PM if you think I can help you. I respond when I can.

posts: 1247   ·   registered: Jan. 7th, 2026   ·   location: Poland
id 8909587
default

Letmebefrank ( member #86994) posted at 12:44 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

This site is far far far better data than this survey you cite as a research study. Know why? Cause there are actually healed people here, lots of them.

This is probably a question for the MODS, but would SI host a survey like this?

Could probably use the same one that Nickerson et al. used, maybe updated with some questions that actually get at the quality of the R. If the site has the ability to reach out to those members who no longer need it, you could get some interesting data.

posts: 448   ·   registered: Jan. 31st, 2026
id 8909594
default

BluerThanBlue ( member #74855) posted at 1:50 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

I’m Catholic and you’re right, forsaking all others isn’t explicitly mentioned in the vows. But as you know from Pre-Cana, fidelity is absolutely expected in a marriage. Do you think keeping your former side piece around qualifies as loving your wife as Christ loved his Church, or honoring her as you vowed? Perhaps you ought to ask a priest; I doubt you’ll get the answer you want.

I also think that you’re weaponizing your faith against your wife. If she’s a devout Catholic who doesn’t believe in divorce, even in the case of adultery, then—given enough time—you think you can bully and manipulate her into accepting OW as your "friend."

Or maybe she’ll eventually get fed up, leave you, and successfully get an annulment from you (as I did with my cheating ex). Because I’ll tell you that doing some extra chores around the house is not going to compensate for the ongoing betrayal and humiliation that your insistence on keeping OW around is inflicting on your wife.

BW, 40s

Divorced WH in 2015; now happily remarried

I edit my comments a lot for spelling, grammar, typos, etc.

posts: 2583   ·   registered: Jul. 13th, 2020
id 8909597
default

LittleMonk ( member #86661) posted at 2:58 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

The study presents some interesting findings, although not necessarily the ones being discussed in this thread. Regarding contact with the AP, however, there is an important distinction between "relationship preservation" and "successful reconciliation" that substantially limits the conclusions that can be drawn.

The researchers initially treated remaining together, reconciling, and healing as largely interchangeable outcomes. Their findings demonstrated that this assumption was problematic. I am glad this is Nickerson's study, as that has been a longstanding criticism of mine regarding her advice on YouTube.

One particularly revealing pathway involved continued dishonesty, unanswered questions, failure to block the AP, and the betrayed being blamed for the affair. Despite these circumstances, 88% of the relationships in that subgroup remained intact.

The authors themselves characterized this pathway as potentially pathological, suggesting emotional dependency, power imbalances, and fear of abandonment as possible explanations.

Blocking the AP was identified as a meaningful predictor of relationship preservation. However, some pathways also demonstrated relatively high preservation rates despite continued contact or failure to block the AP.

These findings establish that NC was not a universal prerequisite for remaining together. They do not establish that continued AP contact was compatible with healthy reconciliation.

Another important distinction concerns the interpretation of positive behaviors as compensating for negative ones. The decision tree analysis identified combinations of behaviors associated with different outcomes. It did not establish that reassurance, affection, household contributions, or other positive behaviors causally offset the consequences of continued AP contact.

Failing to block an AP and actively maintaining a relationship with that person are not equivalent behaviors. The study did not adequately distinguish between them or evaluate the quality and circumstances of continued contact.

The betrayed's preferences are also relevant. Continued contact that is mutually understood and accepted represents a substantially different relational arrangement from continued contact that the betrayed experiences as threatening or unacceptable. The study does not provide sufficient evidence to evaluate those circumstances separately.

In my own reconciliation, my wife did not have NC with the AP for the first 21 months. This was because they still worked together, and some contact was necessary for her to perform her job. However, there was transparency regarding the communication that occurred. Now that she has found a new job, that has shifted to blocked/NC.

A more informative study would distinguish couples who simply remain together from those who achieve sustained relationship satisfaction, restored trust, emotional security, and mutual commitment.

Without those distinctions, high relationship preservation rates risk being interpreted as evidence of successful reconciliation, when the study's own findings demonstrate that the two are not necessarily equivalent.

- LM BH Reconciled

Dday: 12/2024

"The hardest cage to sit in is the one where you hold the key, knowing exactly what freedom looks like on the outside."

posts: 105   ·   registered: Oct. 10th, 2025   ·   location: North Carolina
id 8909601
default

sisoon ( Moderator #31240) posted at 5:04 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

The study was apparently open to anybody who signed onto a website and expressed an interest in staying together after betrayal. What makes you call it 'controlled'?

I am presently fully NC with my OW to accommodate R of the M.

Not while you're looking for ways to justify breaking NC.

Here's another exercise for you: imagine a patient is consulting with you as their physician with the same issue you have. What would you ask? What would you advise?

fBH (me) - on d-day: 66, Married 43, together 45, same sex ap
d-day - 12/22/2010 Recover'd and R'ed
You don't have to like your boundaries. You just have to set and enforce them.

posts: 32344   ·   registered: Feb. 18th, 2011   ·   location: Illinois
id 8909603
default

BluerThanBlue ( member #74855) posted at 5:22 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

Also, I will point out that my W and I are Catholic. Catholic marriage ceremonies have to follow a strict text. Catholics do not promise each other in marriage ceremonies that we will "forsake all others" for the sake of our spouse.

Again, as a practicing Catholic, I have to disagree with your interpretation of Church teaching.

Catholic marriage is a sacramental covenant that demands fidelity, not merely sexual exclusivity. The Catechism (§2380) identifies adultery as a violation of marital fidelity, and §1451 teaches that genuine contrition requires not only sorrow for sin but also a firm resolution not to sin again.

Furthermore, Christ teaches us to remove from our lives those things that lead us into sin (Matthew 5:29–30). Maintaining an unnecessary personal relationship with someone with whom you've already committed adultery is a foreseeable occasion of sin.

You also have an obligation to repair the harm you've caused your wife. If continued contact with your affair partner undermines her trust and your marital reconciliation, insisting on that contact is difficult to reconcile with your obligations as a Catholic husband.

The Church does not teach that every interaction with a former affair partner is automatically sinful. But neither does it teach that fidelity begins and ends with sexual intercourse.

You cannot reduce Catholic morality to a technicality that allows you to preserve a relationship with your affair partner at the expense of your marriage.

The question isn't simply whether you can find a rule permitting contact. It's whether maintaining that contact is consistent with repentance, marital fidelity, and your obligation to love your wife as Christ loves the Church (Ephesians 5:25).

BW, 40s

Divorced WH in 2015; now happily remarried

I edit my comments a lot for spelling, grammar, typos, etc.

posts: 2583   ·   registered: Jul. 13th, 2020
id 8909605
default

InkHulk ( member #80400) posted at 5:22 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

Findings from this study were ambivalent in terms of truth telling. For instance, both answer-
ing and not answering a partner’s questions were found to be part of very effective pathways
to relationship preservation. Clinical experience suggests that there may be temporal dynamics
around truth telling after an affair. On the one hand, it is very common for commitment-breaking
partners to slowly trickle truth out over time. On the other hand, betrayal-experiencing partners
may, initially, be experiencing a trauma-related/protective response of heightened levels of doubt
and suspicion toward anything their partner is saying and thus believe there is more to be told
than has been told. Nevertheless, findings are also compatible with the possibility that after
some affairs, in some relationships, and for some people full disclosure is not the best policy.
Factual completeness may involve painful details which lead to worsening of rumination and
thus hinder emotional repair. Clarifying the truth of the past may also make it harder to envisage
and create a different reality—a different truth—for the future. In light of findings of this study,
truth telling is less likely to be a monolithic phenomenon and a certain therapeutic value in
relationship preservation after infidelity than a multidimensional phenomenon whose therapeutic
value varies across people, relational contexts, and stages of recovery.

I can’t believe this is in this study. After they write in the preamble that their main outcome of relationship preservation is a poor substitute for "good outcomes", and recognize that their are toxic outcomes with BP’s being blamed for A’s, they still conclude that truth telling isn’t necessarily good because of the predictive value it lacks in relationship preservation. I just lost respect for Gottman for signing his name to that.

People are more important than the relationships they are in.

posts: 2988   ·   registered: Jun. 28th, 2022
id 8909607
default

Letmebefrank ( member #86994) posted at 6:41 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

Yeah, InkHulk, I flagged that ridiculous graph too.

This part of it: "Nevertheless, findings are also compatible with the possibility that after some affairs, in some relationships, and for some people full disclosure is not the best policy. Factual completeness may involve painful details which lead to worsening of rumination and thus hinder emotional repair."

I mean, sure, it’s compatible with that possibility, but they have no way of assessing that. Since they didn’t study anything that might actually let them form conclusions about what the "best policy" is, this is just idle musing. Their data might have just as easily picked up a bunch of people who are unhappily rugsweeping, their ‘findings’ are compatible with that too. It’s like they didn’t even consider it.

And this one might even be worse. It’s like an op-ed just dropped into their study. Far as I can tell, they didn’t ask a single question that could support these assertions:

Preserving the original relationship was not, however, found to be simply "the happy ending" relative to an unhappy one of separation. It was an experience which took a variety of forms; which could entail, particularly for betrayal-experiencing partners, complex, negative and unresolved emotions; and which, at least in the short term, could retain a tinge of ongoing deliberation and sense of temporariness about it. Much work remained to be done on restoring trust in the relationship, recommitting full-heartedly to it, and regaining a sense of normalcy and healing, particularly for betrayal-experiencing partners. More positively, findings suggested that an affair did not lead, by default, to a worse relationship. If anything, both commitment-breaking partners who had ended their affair and reconciled and betrayal-experiencing partners who were still together with their original partner were more likely to experience the relationship as improved than not, even if the difference was only marginal for the latter group.

Not saying it’s wrong, but I am saying it’s unconnected to data they generated.

posts: 448   ·   registered: Jan. 31st, 2026
id 8909618
default

InkHulk ( member #80400) posted at 6:58 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

It’s pretty normal for a research paper to make some hypotheses that attempts to interpret their data, which by definition goes beyond their data. But when those explanations utterly disregard their own warnings and then violate basic principles of human ethics, I call utter bullshit.

They call out getting family and friend support as problematic because it is correlated to relationships ending. WTF? Are they really suggesting isolation just to up their fucking stats?

When you read the agony of the stories of the people who fill out these surveys, OUR stories, this shit makes my blood boil. In a world where unmet needs and journey of personal discovery are models used by licensed therapists, having published research, with Gotmann’s name, use bullshit logic to advocate for lies and secrecy, it’s unreal. No wonder we’ve got an active wayward advancing this as "groundbreaking".

People are more important than the relationships they are in.

posts: 2988   ·   registered: Jun. 28th, 2022
id 8909620
default

BluerThanBlue ( member #74855) posted at 8:27 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

They call out getting family and friend support as problematic because it is correlated to relationships ending.

This is exactly what I would expect from therapists who are part of the Reconciliation Industrial Complex.

BW, 40s

Divorced WH in 2015; now happily remarried

I edit my comments a lot for spelling, grammar, typos, etc.

posts: 2583   ·   registered: Jul. 13th, 2020
id 8909623
Cookies on SurvivingInfidelity.com®

SurvivingInfidelity.com® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20260728a 2002-2026 SurvivingInfidelity.com® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy