LJ,
I understand the desire to know every last detail. I went through a similar thing, as if somehow I couldn’t make a decision unless I knew every last excruciating detail. Time, date, place, how long each session lasted, what was said, spit or swallow…And then my best friend got frustrated with me and shook me out of it. He told me to imagine that I had a box that contained every letter, every message, sound recordings of every phone call, film clips of every single kiss and sexual encounter…Absolutely every piece of evidence it was possible to have was going to be in this box. And he said something along the lines of, “What does having every single piece of proof tell you that you do not already know now? Does any of it change the basic facts of what happened? All it does is prove the same few things, over and over again. Why don’t you stop digging, look at what you know now, and accept the truths it is telling you?”
And I realised at that moment that my quest to know every last detail was a way to put off doing what my friend suggested; accepting what had been done, and making the decision based on it. I had been avoiding that, playing mind games with myself, telling myself that I had to have every last scrap of information before I could make an informed decision. I didn’t see it until my friend set me straight.
Honestly, LJ, you really do not need to retrieve any more messages from your wife’s phone. You have more than enough evidence. And would those messages say anything different to the communications that you already have? Your wife did not delete them because they contained anything good, did she? She knew what they said, and she went out of her way to ensure you did not see them. They would only be more professions of love for the OM, how great and exciting the affair is, all the same stuff that your wife is trying to say was a lie, or just stuff she said because she thought the OM wanted to hear it. Almost everyone who has read those denials knows them for what they so obviously are; desperate, ridiculous lies.
However, if you take your wife’s words at face value, that she was actively lying to the OM and leading him on, saying whatever it took to play him for a sucker because she was using him for her own amusement, while simultaneously lying to you and betraying you, what is your wife saying about herself? Does she want you to believe that every time she told the OM he was fantastic and she loved him, she was lying to him? That every time she lied to you and rushed to him to give herself physically to him, it was just a big joke at his expense, and she was having fun making a fool of the OM? How insane is that scenario? And if she wants you to believe that, how can you ever again believe her if she tells you that she loves you, or that she is telling you the truth? She lied to you for a whole year, and now she wants you to believe that she was also lying to the OM for that year too, as if that in some way redeems what she was doing.
She was totally committed to that guy, heart, mind, body and soul. She was prepared to betray you every day for a year, and even to bring the man into the home she shares with you and have sex with him. To photograph herself every day for him, and then smile at you, kiss you, and say she hoped you had a good day. She has the capability within her to do that, and no amount of self-excusing word-play of the kind she is indulging in over in the wayward forum can hide that essential truth. The truths of the affair are written in her actions, in neon letters ten feet high, so tall and so bright that no amount of long and verbose posts can disguise them.
I apologise for the bluntness of what I have written, but I have done it with the best intentions towards you, LJ. I am fifty-one years old now, and while the end is not quite in sight (I hope!), it has made me realise that life really is shorter than we think when we are young. We need to use our time wisely, not fritter it away with people who lie to us or manipulate us because it suits them to do so. I know that for a long time you thought the institution of marriage was pointless, but the fact of the matter is that for most of us, we have just one space in our lives for a ‘significant other’, whether we are married to them or not. Given that the years pass much more quickly than we would like, it makes sense to ensure that whoever we give that ‘significant other’ space to in our lives is the best possible candidate. They should be someone we can trust, and someone who will trust us. Someone who understands commitment, and the obligations and responsibilities that go with saying the words, “I love you”, or, “I do” to another human being. Someone whose honesty with others is based on a solid foundation of honesty with themselves.
So the question you should be asking yourself, LJ, is not so much whether or not condoms were used, or what colour they were, or what acts took place, or whether deleted messages can be retrieved, but whether, given what you now know about her, your wife is the best candidate to fill the ‘significant other’ slot in your life. It is a profound question to ponder, because your future happiness will depend to a great extent on who fills that space in your life, and what they bring into your life.
You are now in your early thirties, which is a period when people really set the course of the rest of their adult lives. Apologies if that sounds patronising; it isn’t meant that way. It is just that being my age has given me some perspective on the stages of life. We can be silly and irresponsible as teenagers, and we start to learn the rules of adult life and who we want to be in our twenties, but it is only really in our thirties that we settle down into the ‘groove’ we are going to be in for the next few decades. If you can take a step back from the fine details of the year-long betrayal, what you are really facing is a question about your future, and who you want sharing it with you, as your supportive, loving, and honest ‘significant other’.
It is a decision that only you can make, and I hope that whatever choices you eventually make, they work out well for you. You are a bright, nice guy, and I hope you have a long and happy life.
[This message edited by M1965 at 7:27 AM, August 9th (Wednesday)]