This is all good stuff to consider.
I really do think those who have a lifetime of self awareness that may falter is a different beast than someone who built those walls very young and has a lifetime / status quo of avoiding feelings. And that makes some sense to me WRT his A.... if not feeling is a status quo, then the BS must find a way to cope with the trauma of dday. Doesn't seem like much of a stretch to get from that lack of feeling/coping skills to an A. However, I think a BS engaging in a relatively long A injects a whole host of deeply rooted issues. IOW, IMO having a ONS after dday strikes me as a trauma response. Not a healthy one, but a trauma response. Having an 18month A is different - it goes beyond a trauma response. It requires superman skills of compartmentalization and cognitive dissonance.
This was/is my concern. It's why I had to have the poly before even doing anything because it screamed at me there could have been others. When I say blindsided, I literally had no idea.
My husband was blindsided by my affair too, but differently. He knew something was wrong he just didn't know what. I didn't even know something was wrong.
Question: You say your H wants to be wanted by you. Do you want him to want you?
This question creates some conflict for me. I don't know why. I am going to say mostly yes. I do want that, or I did. The conflict is mostly due to his affair, because there are days I really don't give a damn what he wants. It feels much more liberating to be in that space, I live there more than I probably should.
Watching porn while receiving a nice sexual service doesn't show much desire for the partner
This is the soul crushing aspect that brought me to finally post on this. It brings a great deal of insecurity up for me, compounded by his overly sexual affair. And, while it doesn't matter, I do wonder when this happened. Is it a result of my own affair? Could be. But, the nagging feeling that I have is there is probably an unhealthy relationship to porn at play here. Sure, my affair probably complicated the issue, but I don't think it's what created the issue.
One of the things that is difficult to me is an overriding desire not to control another person. This comes from FOO and watching my mother dictate my fathers life. I sometimes emotionally, not logically, find myself unable to differentiate some of my boundaries with being a controlling, nagging abusive person my mother was.
I know I am not that at all. I am easy going, too easy going for my own good, and that's in all aspects of my life - from my marriage, my job, and my children. It's an awareness that I came to early in my IC as a WS, and I continue to work on it as these situations arise.
The way my mind plays this is if he wants to watch porn then that's what he wants to do. If I tell him don't do it, then I become the mother in the relationship, which is not a role I want. Then I land on probably a healthier thought which is he needs to decide for himself if this relationship with porn he has is a problem and if he feels that it interferes with having a greater intimacy with me or not. Without him deciding that, I do not think I am interested in trying to be the one to control it. I can control if I participate in it, and I can control if we stay married without him having that epiphany. So, it's pretty much with that framing that I will likely start the conversation tonight.
It's a very difficult thing for me to look at, I have been trying to ignore too many things because it makes me feel defeated, as if divorce is going to be inevitable. I say I don't fear a divorce, but maybe that's just tough talk.
Ask for what you want
I definitely will. I don't fear that. And, honestly as bad as this all sounds, I do think he will try and comply with what I ask. I just don't want him to comply because I ask though. I want him to comply because I inspire him in some way. Tall order, and I do fear that part is too much to ask (WS hat comes on)
OTOH, if you put your BS clothes on and make demands, maybe he'll step up.
Demands are harder for me than requests. But, I know why you use the word. I have made many BS lines in the sand, but I never do without weighing things with my WS hat. I am not sure how you would ever separate that, I have been in the WS role for years now, the BS role for months.
HO how often does he watch porn while you have intimacy? If he is doing this more than "regular" intimacy? If he is doing this more I would set up a boundary if this makes you uncomfortable.
While our average number per week is probably down in the last couple of months, I will give you what is average for us normally. We typically have sex 3 or 4 times a week. Porn is used probably most of those sessions. This week, prior to last night we have had sex twice. Once with and once without. There is no difference in performance, in fact I would say his erections are better without it. I would say it's much more common for it to be used than not. He also uses it on days we do not have sex. I don't know what the norm is for that. He doesn't avoid doing things to have porn time, it's not multiple times a day or anything. Overall, I probably would call it more of a growing problem rather than seeing classic signs of addiction to it?
I will respond more to the other posts, this one is getting too long.