Rynoz
I read your thread last night and meant to comment on it but really had no time until now.
First, a general observation. Your initial post seemed a little aimless, full of confusion and second guessing yourself. This is entirely natural due to the shock you are going through. With each reply you've made, I see you getting more confidence and sure of your position. That is very commendable. Many people have told you "This is NOT your fault.. don't let her drive the narrative" Well, I'm going to reiterate that. You did nothing to deserve this. Now is not the time for dithering, it's the time for action and practical thought. You are on the way towards that goal.
Second, very important. You already are on board with this, but again, I'm here to reiterate a lot of good advice you are getting or are in the process of deciding on. Open Relationships are usually unfair to someone. No offense to any SI members who are in one. In my experience, the pattern usually is there's a partner suggesting and a partner reluctantly agreeing. The partner reluctantly agreeing always seem to get screwed, and I don't mean in the fun way. Again, not with 100% of them, just the 100% that I personally have seen. It usually works out to "I want to fuck someone outside of the marriage, and I want you to hang out and make nice-nice about it so we can all look like rational, nice people". If that sounds familiar, it's exactly the shell game your wife is trying to pull on you now. The hysterical bonding, the love bombing you've been experiencing lately? The great dialogue? That was a setup to get you to agree to a situation you already have a problem with -- I've read your responses.
You're your own man on this, it's your decision, but I can guess the outcome-- you're going to be miserable in this situation,and it will just postpone the inevitable divorce.
Third thing:
I appreciate all of the quick responses. Thank you. This is really tough. I an going to be filling the papers next week after I get paid. Nothing I can do before that. I have reviewed the 180 and will start that in the meantime. I have never been and don’t plan on being anyone’scuckold. That’s not in me. I agree that talk = nothing. There is no reasoning or rational thought process. Just doesn’t make sense. But when the papers drop there is a possibility that that fog may clear and there can be some rational conversation at least. At this point I have no expectations except for what I plan to do. My plans are only for myself.
I am admiring your tonal shift.. VERY good indeed. You have already discovered that that woman you loved (maybe still love) was indeed capable of the most base form of betrayal. Without warning, she has wrecked your marriage. I know you keep Reconciliation around as your plan B and I would say don't rule it out. However, you won't be reconciling so much as building something new. The burden of much of the work will be on her, not you. Now, me, based upon what you have written here? I'm not getting that confident vibe that she's going to really put in any effort at all. I suspect, strongly that any reconciliation from her would be an act for her to play for time, so she can (yes, here's that phrase again) cake eat until she's punched her ticket and created an exit strategy. Your comments above indicate you seem to know this in your heart of hearts. She wants you to be "calm and rational" about her cuckolding you. In my opinion she's asking WAYYYY too much here. It's humiliating and cruel, you know that already.
And a fourth thing:
She really wants me to keep quiet about what’s going on. Everyone doesn’t need to know our business. I guess there is merit in that. However, I want to run and tell everyone but I just think that would be a weak move in itself. Just out telling. I don’t know. I know she had isolated herself from her friends. She told just a couple about the blowout when she told me. Her good friends. I overheard her talking to one on the phone like they were catching up. I know they told her they weren’t with this bullshit. I know because I spoke to them too. So she is kind of on an island. Her advice is only coming from one place. That place confirms her bullshit.
Of course she doesn't want anyone to know what's going on and to keep out of your business! She's already trying to gaslight you that the reasonable, rational, "Civil" thing to do is to have her go be with another guy for a year AS HER COUNTEROFFER FOR RECONCILIATION. Seriously? That's her plan A? I have a bigger chance of becoming a Chinese Jet Pilot than you do of expecting to have your wife and marriage back all lovey dovey and like this never happened. She's LYING to you. She's lied all along. It's what cheaters do. From here on out just save yourself some heartache and go with the basic theory that anything coming out of her mouth can't be trusted any more. Because it can't. She made a conscious decision to betray you with another man. She hid the information from you successfully and gambled you'd be so co-dependent, you'd eat the shit sandwich she was serving up to you and say "Yum, honey!" back to her. Thank God you are seeing through that.
What next? That's always up to you. I personally think you are doing the right thing. If by some miracle she goes whole hog on reconciliation, does the work, gets the therapy, reads the books, and convinces you just how stricken with grief she is for causing you so much pain and anguish, then, yeah.. maybe R is possible, yaaaay. Hmmm.. well, it's just me, but I don't see her caring that much. Watch yourself and jump into that 180 method everyone keeps recommending. You will be amazed at HER tonal shift when you stop entertaining her bullshit for even one more second. The next time she brings up the subject of your relationship, just say "I'm very sorry, we don't have a relationship any more. You destroyed that by sleeping with another man. You are still in a relationship with him and you care little or nothing for me or you wouldn't suggest this open relationship idea, which I roundly reject. Please sign the papers and confine any further information between us to practical matters, like finances, property settlement, child custody and support."
Oh, and that "tell everyone" thing.. right now, it's meant for you to reach out to your family and friends support network. NOT to shame her (not that she deserves any consideration), but to communicate with people that can help you heal.. your family, her family, your friends. Be discrete, of course.. BUT DO NOT LIE TO PROTECT HER LIES. Once the divorce agreement is filed and signed, you can put up billboards, there's not much she can do to you then.
Just like everyone here, I wish you STRENGTH, SUCCESS and a swift resolution to her betrayal. You're a good guy, you sure as hell didn't deserve this.