(((Noah))) So proud of you for having "The Talk". I know it wasn't easy.
Your wife's reaction sounds like mine. I didn't scream. I didn't yell. I didn't break things, hit him, toss him out of the house, or pack up his stuff.
I was very, very calm. I sat through a 2 hour car ride with our children and an entire Christmas Day with my H's family. No one except him knew anything was wrong.
I will guarantee you that anger will come later. Please don't be surprised. If you do a lot of reading on here, especially in general or JFO, you'll start to understand what a BS may feel months after d-day. For me, real raging anger set in in September....9 months after D-day #1, 6 months after D-day #2.
Hearing you talk about NC, though, it's glaringly obvious that you're not 100% all in.
I agree with cdnmommy (
Go NC. Period. Not because you want your M but because it is the right thing to do.
) You need to drop that OW like a hot potato, not wait around for your wife to decide whether or not you're going to stay together and THEN you would stop talking to OW. Your wife may decide in a week, in a year, in TEN years, that she wants to split up. There's never a guarantee in relationships. Are you going to keep an OW on the back burner the whole time just in case? It kinda sounds like maybe you might have some issues with the idea of being single for a little while - even if your wife leaves, what's wrong with being on your own for a bit until you meet someone who you can have an honorable relationship with? (i.e. NOT the OW)
When my H was about to confess his two other OW (on D-day #2), he tried to make me promise that I wouldn't leave him before he told me what he had to confess. I refused. I told him the most I would promise was that I wouldn't leave "right away". I'd think it over first. And he did go ahead and 'fess up, thank God, despite his fear that telling me about the other two OW was going to kill our marriage. It means a lot to me that he did that.
I sent her a couple brief messages over the weekend. Like "busy" or "I can't talk now" type deals. I haven't said anything of substance to her and I've ignored her calls since. So NC hasn't been officially done but I'm going to talk to my wife, offer it and try to establish official, firm NC tonight.
This has gotta stop though. My husband did not stop talking to the OW after my d-day, and it was HEARTBREAKING when I found out later. Please please don't. You will cause SO MUCH more damage via contact after d-day than what you did before it. Because now your wife KNOWS and you've SEEN her reaction and her hurt. And if you continue to contact the OW, you're now doing it KNOWING that you're hurting your wife on purpose. Why are you replying to her messages? If you're afraid of pissing off the OW....well you've already told your wife, so that horse is out of the barn. No need to fear her now, as long as you've been honest with your wife and there aren't other secrets that the OW can reveal. If you're afraid of seeming rude to her, or hurting her feelings.....then you have a lot of work to do, because that needs to be the FURTHEST thing from your mind if you want your marriage to survive. If your wife finds out you've continued to reply to her through d-day and beyond, how are you going to explain that? Seriously - try to run the dialogue in your mind. Can you imagine telling your betrayed spouse that the reason you didn't stop replying to OW and continued to hide your actions and betray her (your wife) was "good manners"?
You also need to make sure that your NC letter is not what my H tried to send after D-day #1, which was basically a love letter in disguise...."I've been thinking a lot about our time together"....meant to allow her to think that he was pining away over her.
You need to tell OW that your wife is important to you, your family is important to you. That what you did with OW was a mistake and you regret it. That you will not be contacting her again, and you will not accept any contact from her either. And for goodness' sake, don't apologize to her or say anything about treating her (OW) unfairly.
Keep it short.
Let your wife see it and edit as necessary.
Send it and never look back.
If you and your wife don't stay together, cross that bridge when you get to it. You don't need to keep OW under it like some kind of troll, waiting to pounce on you if your marriage falls apart. You move on. You tell her to move on. People do it ALL the time.
It really sounds like you want to do right, Noah. It sounds like you're a little foggy maybe, but that behind the fog you know what the right thing to do is. Please take the plunge and just DO the right thing without giving it any further thought. Go NC, prove to your wife you're all in, and do what you need to do to fix YOU so that regardless of what happens with your current marriage you can be a happy man and a father your children will be proud of.
Wishing you and your wife the best.